Replace public library list with shared lib sonames (part 2/2)

This commit updates interface of libdl.c.

1. android_init_namespaces is replaces with android_init_anonymous_namespace
2. added 2 arguments to android_create_namespace to specify linked namespace
   and the list of shared libraries sonames.
3. symbol lookup does not get past boundary libraries (added check and test for it).

Bug: http://b/26833548
Bug: http://b/21879602
Test: bionic-unit-tests --gtest_filter=dl*:Dl*
Change-Id: I32921da487a02e5bd0d2fc528904d1228394bfb9
This commit is contained in:
Dimitry Ivanov 2017-02-03 14:07:34 -08:00
parent 7d429d3c48
commit 7a34b9d57a
20 changed files with 524 additions and 126 deletions

View file

@ -44,6 +44,7 @@ LIBC_PLATFORM {
android_set_application_target_sdk_version;
android_get_LD_LIBRARY_PATH;
android_update_LD_LIBRARY_PATH;
android_init_namespaces;
android_init_anonymous_namespace;
android_create_namespace;
android_link_namespaces;
} LIBC_N;

View file

@ -43,6 +43,7 @@ LIBC_PLATFORM {
android_set_application_target_sdk_version;
android_get_LD_LIBRARY_PATH;
android_update_LD_LIBRARY_PATH;
android_init_namespaces;
android_init_anonymous_namespace;
android_create_namespace;
android_link_namespaces;
} LIBC_N;

View file

@ -72,8 +72,8 @@ __attribute__((__weak__, visibility("default")))
uint32_t __loader_android_get_application_target_sdk_version();
__attribute__((__weak__, visibility("default")))
bool __loader_android_init_namespaces(const char* public_ns_sonames,
const char* anon_ns_library_path);
bool __loader_android_init_anonymous_namespace(const char* shared_libs_sonames,
const char* library_search_path);
__attribute__((__weak__, visibility("default")))
struct android_namespace_t* __loader_android_create_namespace(
@ -85,6 +85,12 @@ struct android_namespace_t* __loader_android_create_namespace(
struct android_namespace_t* parent,
const void* caller_addr);
__attribute__((__weak__, visibility("default")))
bool __loader_android_link_namespaces(
struct android_namespace_t* namespace_from,
struct android_namespace_t* namespace_to,
const char* shared_libs_sonames);
__attribute__((__weak__, visibility("default")))
void __loader_android_dlwarning(void* obj, void (*f)(void*, const char*));
@ -146,9 +152,9 @@ uint32_t android_get_application_target_sdk_version() {
return __loader_android_get_application_target_sdk_version();
}
bool android_init_namespaces(const char* public_ns_sonames,
const char* anon_ns_library_path) {
return __loader_android_init_namespaces(public_ns_sonames, anon_ns_library_path);
bool android_init_anonymous_namespace(const char* shared_libs_sonames,
const char* library_search_path) {
return __loader_android_init_anonymous_namespace(shared_libs_sonames, library_search_path);
}
struct android_namespace_t* android_create_namespace(const char* name,
@ -167,6 +173,12 @@ struct android_namespace_t* android_create_namespace(const char* name,
caller_addr);
}
bool android_link_namespaces(struct android_namespace_t* namespace_from,
struct android_namespace_t* namespace_to,
const char* shared_libs_sonames) {
return __loader_android_link_namespaces(namespace_from, namespace_to, shared_libs_sonames);
}
void android_dlwarning(void* obj, void (*f)(void*, const char*)) {
__loader_android_dlwarning(obj, f);
}

View file

@ -43,6 +43,7 @@ LIBC_PLATFORM {
android_set_application_target_sdk_version;
android_get_LD_LIBRARY_PATH;
android_update_LD_LIBRARY_PATH;
android_init_namespaces;
android_init_anonymous_namespace;
android_create_namespace;
android_link_namespaces;
} LIBC_N;

View file

@ -43,6 +43,7 @@ LIBC_PLATFORM {
android_set_application_target_sdk_version;
android_get_LD_LIBRARY_PATH;
android_update_LD_LIBRARY_PATH;
android_init_namespaces;
android_init_anonymous_namespace;
android_create_namespace;
android_link_namespaces;
} LIBC_N;

View file

@ -43,6 +43,7 @@ LIBC_PLATFORM {
android_set_application_target_sdk_version;
android_get_LD_LIBRARY_PATH;
android_update_LD_LIBRARY_PATH;
android_init_namespaces;
android_init_anonymous_namespace;
android_create_namespace;
android_link_namespaces;
} LIBC_N;

View file

@ -43,6 +43,7 @@ LIBC_PLATFORM {
android_set_application_target_sdk_version;
android_get_LD_LIBRARY_PATH;
android_update_LD_LIBRARY_PATH;
android_init_namespaces;
android_init_anonymous_namespace;
android_create_namespace;
android_link_namespaces;
} LIBC_N;

View file

@ -43,6 +43,7 @@ LIBC_PLATFORM {
android_set_application_target_sdk_version;
android_get_LD_LIBRARY_PATH;
android_update_LD_LIBRARY_PATH;
android_init_namespaces;
android_init_anonymous_namespace;
android_create_namespace;
android_link_namespaces;
} LIBC_N;

View file

@ -30,8 +30,6 @@
#include "private/ScopedPthreadMutexLocker.h"
#include "private/ThreadLocalBuffer.h"
/* This file hijacks the symbols stubbed out in libdl.so. */
static pthread_mutex_t g_dl_mutex = PTHREAD_RECURSIVE_MUTEX_INITIALIZER_NP;
static char* __bionic_set_dlerror(char* new_value) {
@ -155,12 +153,12 @@ void __android_dlwarning(void* obj, void (*f)(void*, const char*)) {
get_dlwarning(obj, f);
}
bool __android_init_namespaces(const char* public_ns_sonames,
const char* anon_ns_library_path) {
bool __android_init_anonymous_namespace(const char* shared_libs_sonames,
const char* library_search_path) {
ScopedPthreadMutexLocker locker(&g_dl_mutex);
bool success = init_namespaces(public_ns_sonames, anon_ns_library_path);
bool success = init_anonymous_namespace(shared_libs_sonames, library_search_path);
if (!success) {
__bionic_format_dlerror("android_init_namespaces failed", linker_get_error_buffer());
__bionic_format_dlerror("android_init_anonymous_namespace failed", linker_get_error_buffer());
}
return success;
@ -190,6 +188,20 @@ android_namespace_t* __android_create_namespace(const char* name,
return result;
}
bool __android_link_namespaces(android_namespace_t* namespace_from,
android_namespace_t* namespace_to,
const char* shared_libs_sonames) {
ScopedPthreadMutexLocker locker(&g_dl_mutex);
bool success = link_namespaces(namespace_from, namespace_to, shared_libs_sonames);
if (!success) {
__bionic_format_dlerror("android_link_namespaces failed", linker_get_error_buffer());
}
return success;
}
void __cfi_fail(uint64_t CallSiteTypeId, void* Ptr, void *DiagData, void *CallerPc) {
CFIShadowWriter::CfiFail(CallSiteTypeId, Ptr, DiagData, CallerPc);
}
@ -226,15 +238,15 @@ static const char ANDROID_LIBDL_STRTAB[] =
// 01234567890 1234567890123456789012345678901234567890123456789012 3456789012345678901234567890123456789
"dlopen_ext\0__loader_android_set_application_target_sdk_version\0__loader_android_get_application_targ"
// 3*
// 000000000011111 111112222222222333333333344444444 4455555555556666666666777777777788 8888888899999999 99
// 012345678901234 567890123456789012345678901234567 8901234567890123456789012345678901 2345678901234567 89
"et_sdk_version\0__loader_android_init_namespaces\0__loader_android_create_namespace\0__loader_dlvsym\0__"
// 000000000011111 111112222222222333333333344444444445555555 5556666666666777777777788888888889 999999999
// 012345678901234 567890123456789012345678901234567890123456 7890123456789012345678901234567890 123456789
"et_sdk_version\0__loader_android_init_anonymous_namespace\0__loader_android_create_namespace\0__loader_"
// 4*
// 0000000000111111111122222 222223333333333444 4444444555555555566666666667777 77777788888888889999999999
// 0123456789012345678901234 567890123456789012 3456789012345678901234567890123 45678901234567890123456789
"loader_android_dlwarning\0__loader_cfi_fail\0"
// 0000000 000111111111122222222223333 333333444444444455 555555556666666666777777777788888 888889999999999
// 0123456 789012345678901234567890123 456789012345678901 234567890123456789012345678901234 567890123456789
"dlvsym\0__loader_android_dlwarning\0__loader_cfi_fail\0__loader_android_link_namespaces\0"
#if defined(__arm__)
// 443
// 485
"__loader_dl_unwind_find_exidx\0"
#endif
;
@ -256,13 +268,14 @@ static ElfW(Sym) g_libdl_symtab[] = {
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(183, &__android_dlopen_ext, 1),
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(211, &__android_set_application_target_sdk_version, 1),
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(263, &__android_get_application_target_sdk_version, 1),
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(315, &__android_init_namespaces, 1),
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(348, &__android_create_namespace, 1),
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(382, &__dlvsym, 1),
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(398, &__android_dlwarning, 1),
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(425, &__cfi_fail, 1),
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(315, &__android_init_anonymous_namespace, 1),
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(357, &__android_create_namespace, 1),
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(391, &__dlvsym, 1),
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(407, &__android_dlwarning, 1),
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(434, &__cfi_fail, 1),
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(452, &__android_link_namespaces, 1),
#if defined(__arm__)
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(443, &__dl_unwind_find_exidx, 1),
ELFW(SYM_INITIALIZER)(485, &__dl_unwind_find_exidx, 1),
#endif
};
@ -279,9 +292,9 @@ static ElfW(Sym) g_libdl_symtab[] = {
// Note that adding any new symbols here requires stubbing them out in libdl.
static unsigned g_libdl_buckets[1] = { 1 };
#if defined(__arm__)
static unsigned g_libdl_chains[] = { 0, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 0 };
static unsigned g_libdl_chains[] = { 0, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 0 };
#else
static unsigned g_libdl_chains[] = { 0, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 0 };
static unsigned g_libdl_chains[] = { 0, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 0 };
#endif
static uint8_t __libdl_info_buf[sizeof(soinfo)] __attribute__((aligned(8)));

View file

@ -185,10 +185,7 @@ static bool is_greylisted(const char* name, const soinfo* needed_by) {
static const char* const* g_default_ld_paths;
static std::vector<std::string> g_ld_preload_names;
static bool g_public_namespace_initialized;
// TODO (dimitry): Remove once interface between libnativeloader and the linker is updated
static std::unordered_set<std::string> g_public_namespace_sonames;
static bool g_anonymous_namespace_initialized;
#if STATS
struct linker_stats_t {
@ -656,11 +653,18 @@ typedef linked_list_t<soinfo> SoinfoLinkedList;
typedef linked_list_t<const char> StringLinkedList;
typedef std::vector<LoadTask*> LoadTaskList;
enum walk_action_result_t : uint32_t {
kWalkStop = 0,
kWalkContinue = 1,
kWalkSkip = 2
};
// This function walks down the tree of soinfo dependencies
// in breadth-first order and
// * calls action(soinfo* si) for each node, and
// * terminates walk if action returns false.
// * terminates walk if action returns kWalkStop
// * skips children of the node if action
// return kWalkSkip
//
// walk_dependencies_tree returns false if walk was terminated
// by the action and true otherwise.
@ -679,23 +683,30 @@ static bool walk_dependencies_tree(soinfo* root_soinfos[], size_t root_soinfos_s
continue;
}
if (!action(si)) {
walk_action_result_t result = action(si);
if (result == kWalkStop) {
return false;
}
visited.push_back(si);
si->get_children().for_each([&](soinfo* child) {
visit_list.push_back(child);
});
if (result != kWalkSkip) {
si->get_children().for_each([&](soinfo* child) {
visit_list.push_back(child);
});
}
}
return true;
}
static const ElfW(Sym)* dlsym_handle_lookup(soinfo* root, soinfo* skip_until,
soinfo** found, SymbolName& symbol_name,
static const ElfW(Sym)* dlsym_handle_lookup(android_namespace_t* ns,
soinfo* root,
soinfo* skip_until,
soinfo** found,
SymbolName& symbol_name,
const version_info* vi) {
const ElfW(Sym)* result = nullptr;
bool skip_lookup = skip_until != nullptr;
@ -703,20 +714,24 @@ static const ElfW(Sym)* dlsym_handle_lookup(soinfo* root, soinfo* skip_until,
walk_dependencies_tree(&root, 1, [&](soinfo* current_soinfo) {
if (skip_lookup) {
skip_lookup = current_soinfo != skip_until;
return true;
return kWalkContinue;
}
if (!ns->is_accessible(current_soinfo)) {
return kWalkSkip;
}
if (!current_soinfo->find_symbol_by_name(symbol_name, vi, &result)) {
result = nullptr;
return false;
return kWalkStop;
}
if (result != nullptr) {
*found = current_soinfo;
return false;
return kWalkStop;
}
return true;
return kWalkContinue;
});
return result;
@ -731,8 +746,10 @@ static const ElfW(Sym)* dlsym_linear_lookup(android_namespace_t* ns,
// This is used by dlsym(3). It performs symbol lookup only within the
// specified soinfo object and its dependencies in breadth first order.
static const ElfW(Sym)* dlsym_handle_lookup(soinfo* si, soinfo** found,
const char* name, const version_info* vi) {
static const ElfW(Sym)* dlsym_handle_lookup(soinfo* si,
soinfo** found,
const char* name,
const version_info* vi) {
// According to man dlopen(3) and posix docs in the case when si is handle
// of the main executable we need to search not only in the executable and its
// dependencies but also in all libraries loaded with RTLD_GLOBAL.
@ -745,7 +762,11 @@ static const ElfW(Sym)* dlsym_handle_lookup(soinfo* si, soinfo** found,
}
SymbolName symbol_name(name);
return dlsym_handle_lookup(si, nullptr, found, symbol_name, vi);
// note that the namespace is not the namespace associated with caller_addr
// we use ns associated with root si intentionally here. Using caller_ns
// causes problems when user uses dlopen_ext to open a library in the separate
// namespace and then calls dlsym() on the handle.
return dlsym_handle_lookup(si->get_primary_namespace(), si, nullptr, found, symbol_name, vi);
}
/* This is used by dlsym(3) to performs a global symbol lookup. If the
@ -800,8 +821,14 @@ static const ElfW(Sym)* dlsym_linear_lookup(android_namespace_t* ns,
// case we already did it.
if (s == nullptr && caller != nullptr &&
(caller->get_rtld_flags() & RTLD_GLOBAL) == 0) {
return dlsym_handle_lookup(caller->get_local_group_root(),
(handle == RTLD_NEXT) ? caller : nullptr, found, symbol_name, vi);
soinfo* local_group_root = caller->get_local_group_root();
return dlsym_handle_lookup(local_group_root->get_primary_namespace(),
local_group_root,
(handle == RTLD_NEXT) ? caller : nullptr,
found,
symbol_name,
vi);
}
if (s != nullptr) {
@ -1542,8 +1569,12 @@ bool find_libraries(android_namespace_t* ns,
(start_with != nullptr && add_as_children) ? &start_with : soinfos,
(start_with != nullptr && add_as_children) ? 1 : soinfos_count,
[&] (soinfo* si) {
local_group.push_back(si);
return true;
if (ns->is_accessible(si)) {
local_group.push_back(si);
return kWalkContinue;
} else {
return kWalkSkip;
}
});
bool linked = local_group.visit([&](soinfo* si) {
@ -2001,39 +2032,42 @@ int do_dlclose(void* handle) {
return 0;
}
bool init_namespaces(const char* public_ns_sonames, const char* anon_ns_library_path) {
if (g_public_namespace_initialized) {
DL_ERR("public namespace has already been initialized.");
bool init_anonymous_namespace(const char* shared_lib_sonames, const char* library_search_path) {
if (g_anonymous_namespace_initialized) {
DL_ERR("anonymous namespace has already been initialized.");
return false;
}
if (public_ns_sonames == nullptr || public_ns_sonames[0] == '\0') {
DL_ERR("error initializing public namespace: the list of public libraries is empty.");
return false;
}
auto sonames = android::base::Split(public_ns_sonames, ":");
ProtectedDataGuard guard;
g_public_namespace_sonames = std::unordered_set<std::string>(sonames.begin(), sonames.end());
g_public_namespace_initialized = true;
g_anonymous_namespace_initialized = true;
// create anonymous namespace
// When the caller is nullptr - create_namespace will take global group
// from the anonymous namespace, which is fine because anonymous namespace
// is still pointing to the default one.
android_namespace_t* anon_ns =
create_namespace(nullptr, "(anonymous)", nullptr, anon_ns_library_path,
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_REGULAR, nullptr, &g_default_namespace);
create_namespace(nullptr,
"(anonymous)",
nullptr,
library_search_path,
// TODO (dimitry): change to isolated eventually.
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_REGULAR,
nullptr,
&g_default_namespace);
if (anon_ns == nullptr) {
g_public_namespace_initialized = false;
g_anonymous_namespace_initialized = false;
return false;
}
if (!link_namespaces(anon_ns, &g_default_namespace, shared_lib_sonames)) {
g_anonymous_namespace_initialized = false;
return false;
}
g_anonymous_namespace = anon_ns;
return true;
}
@ -2051,8 +2085,8 @@ android_namespace_t* create_namespace(const void* caller_addr,
uint64_t type,
const char* permitted_when_isolated_path,
android_namespace_t* parent_namespace) {
if (!g_public_namespace_initialized) {
DL_ERR("cannot create namespace: public namespace is not initialized.");
if (!g_anonymous_namespace_initialized) {
DL_ERR("cannot create namespace: anonymous namespace is not initialized.");
return nullptr;
}
@ -2089,13 +2123,36 @@ android_namespace_t* create_namespace(const void* caller_addr,
add_soinfos_to_namespace(get_shared_group(parent_namespace), ns);
}
// link it to default namespace
// TODO (dimitry): replace this with user-supplied link once interface is updated
ns->add_linked_namespace(&g_default_namespace, g_public_namespace_sonames);
return ns;
}
bool link_namespaces(android_namespace_t* namespace_from,
android_namespace_t* namespace_to,
const char* shared_lib_sonames) {
if (namespace_to == nullptr) {
namespace_to = &g_default_namespace;
}
if (namespace_from == nullptr) {
DL_ERR("error linking namespaces: namespace_from is null.");
return false;
}
if (shared_lib_sonames == nullptr || shared_lib_sonames[0] == '\0') {
DL_ERR("error linking namespaces \"%s\"->\"%s\": the list of shared libraries is empty.",
namespace_from->get_name(), namespace_to->get_name());
return false;
}
auto sonames = android::base::Split(shared_lib_sonames, ":");
std::unordered_set<std::string> sonames_set(sonames.begin(), sonames.end());
ProtectedDataGuard guard;
namespace_from->add_linked_namespace(namespace_to, sonames_set);
return true;
}
ElfW(Addr) call_ifunc_resolver(ElfW(Addr) resolver_addr) {
typedef ElfW(Addr) (*ifunc_resolver_t)(void);
ifunc_resolver_t ifunc_resolver = reinterpret_cast<ifunc_resolver_t>(resolver_addr);

View file

@ -160,7 +160,7 @@ enum {
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_ISOLATED,
};
bool init_namespaces(const char* public_ns_sonames, const char* anon_ns_library_path);
bool init_anonymous_namespace(const char* shared_lib_sonames, const char* library_search_path);
android_namespace_t* create_namespace(const void* caller_addr,
const char* name,
const char* ld_library_path,
@ -169,4 +169,8 @@ android_namespace_t* create_namespace(const void* caller_addr,
const char* permitted_when_isolated_path,
android_namespace_t* parent_namespace);
bool link_namespaces(android_namespace_t* namespace_from,
android_namespace_t* namespace_to,
const char* shared_lib_sonames);
#endif

View file

@ -27,6 +27,7 @@
*/
#include "linker_namespaces.h"
#include "linker_soinfo.h"
#include "linker_utils.h"
#include <vector>
@ -57,3 +58,23 @@ bool android_namespace_t::is_accessible(const std::string& file) {
return false;
}
bool android_namespace_t::is_accessible(soinfo* s) {
std::vector<soinfo*> soinfos;
soinfos.push_back(s);
s->get_parents().for_each([&](soinfo* parent_si) {
soinfos.push_back(parent_si);
});
return std::find_if(soinfos.begin(), soinfos.end(), [this](soinfo* si) {
if (si->get_primary_namespace() == this) {
return true;
}
const android_namespace_list_t& secondary_namespaces = si->get_secondary_namespaces();
if (secondary_namespaces.find(this) != secondary_namespaces.end()) {
return true;
}
return false;
}) != soinfos.end();
}

View file

@ -118,6 +118,11 @@ struct android_namespace_t {
// always returns true for not isolated namespace.
bool is_accessible(const std::string& path);
// Returns true if si is accessible from this namespace. A soinfo
// is considered accessible when it belongs to this namespace
// or one of it's parent soinfos belongs to this namespace.
bool is_accessible(soinfo* si);
private:
const char* name_;
bool is_isolated_;

View file

@ -634,6 +634,11 @@ void soinfo::add_secondary_namespace(android_namespace_t* secondary_ns) {
secondary_namespaces_.push_back(secondary_ns);
}
android_namespace_list_t& soinfo::get_secondary_namespaces() {
CHECK(has_min_version(3));
return secondary_namespaces_;
}
ElfW(Addr) soinfo::resolve_symbol_address(const ElfW(Sym)* s) const {
if (ELF_ST_TYPE(s->st_info) == STT_GNU_IFUNC) {
return call_ifunc_resolver(s->st_value + load_bias);
@ -695,7 +700,6 @@ soinfo* soinfo::get_local_group_root() const {
return local_group_root_;
}
void soinfo::set_mapped_by_caller(bool mapped_by_caller) {
if (mapped_by_caller) {
flags_ |= FLAG_MAPPED_BY_CALLER;

View file

@ -263,6 +263,7 @@ struct soinfo {
const std::vector<std::string>& get_dt_runpath() const;
android_namespace_t* get_primary_namespace();
void add_secondary_namespace(android_namespace_t* secondary_ns);
android_namespace_list_t& get_secondary_namespaces();
void set_mapped_by_caller(bool reserved_map);
bool is_mapped_by_caller() const;

View file

@ -22,16 +22,15 @@
__BEGIN_DECLS
/*
* Initializes public and anonymous namespaces. The public_ns_sonames is the list of sonames
* to be included into public namespace separated by colon. Example: "libc.so:libm.so:libdl.so".
* The libraries in this list should be loaded prior to this call.
* Initializes anonymous namespaces. The shared_libs_sonames is the list of sonames
* to be shared by default namespace separated by colon. Example: "libc.so:libm.so:libdl.so".
*
* The anon_ns_library_path is the search path for anonymous namespace. The anonymous namespace
* The library_search_path is the search path for anonymous namespace. The anonymous namespace
* is used in the case when linker cannot identify the caller of dlopen/dlsym. This happens
* for the code not loaded by dynamic linker; for example calls from the mono-compiled code.
*/
extern bool android_init_namespaces(const char* public_ns_sonames,
const char* anon_ns_library_path);
extern bool android_init_anonymous_namespace(const char* shared_libs_sonames,
const char* library_search_path);
enum {
@ -86,6 +85,10 @@ extern struct android_namespace_t* android_create_namespace(const char* name,
const char* permitted_when_isolated_path,
android_namespace_t* parent);
extern bool android_link_namespaces(android_namespace_t* from,
android_namespace_t* to,
const char* shared_libs_sonames);
extern void android_set_application_target_sdk_version(uint32_t target);
__END_DECLS

View file

@ -617,41 +617,54 @@ void DlExtRelroSharingTest::SpawnChildrenAndMeasurePss(const char* lib, bool sha
// Testing namespaces
static const char* g_public_lib = "libnstest_public.so";
// These are libs shared with default namespace
static const std::string g_core_shared_libs = "libc.so:libc++.so:libdl.so:libm.so";
TEST(dlext, ns_smoke) {
static const char* root_lib = "libnstest_root.so";
std::string path = std::string("libc.so:libc++.so:libdl.so:libm.so:") + g_public_lib;
std::string shared_libs = g_core_shared_libs + ":" + g_public_lib;
ASSERT_FALSE(android_init_namespaces("", nullptr));
ASSERT_STREQ("android_init_namespaces failed: error initializing public namespace: "
"the list of public libraries is empty.", dlerror());
ASSERT_FALSE(android_init_anonymous_namespace("", nullptr));
ASSERT_STREQ("android_init_anonymous_namespace failed: error linking namespaces"
" \"(anonymous)\"->\"(default)\": the list of shared libraries is empty.",
dlerror());
const std::string lib_public_path = get_testlib_root() + "/public_namespace_libs/" + g_public_lib;
void* handle_public = dlopen(lib_public_path.c_str(), RTLD_NOW);
ASSERT_TRUE(handle_public != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_namespaces(path.c_str(), nullptr)) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_anonymous_namespace(shared_libs.c_str(), nullptr)) << dlerror();
// Check that libraries added to public namespace are not NODELETE
dlclose(handle_public);
handle_public = dlopen(lib_public_path.c_str(), RTLD_NOW | RTLD_NOLOAD);
ASSERT_TRUE(handle_public == nullptr);
ASSERT_EQ(std::string("dlopen failed: library \"") + lib_public_path +
"\" wasn't loaded and RTLD_NOLOAD prevented it", dlerror());
handle_public = dlopen(lib_public_path.c_str(), RTLD_NOW);
// create "public namespace", share limited set of public libraries with
android_namespace_t* ns1 =
android_create_namespace("private", nullptr,
android_create_namespace("private",
nullptr,
(get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs").c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_REGULAR, nullptr, nullptr);
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_REGULAR,
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(ns1 != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns1, nullptr, shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
android_namespace_t* ns2 =
android_create_namespace("private_isolated", nullptr,
android_create_namespace("private_isolated",
nullptr,
(get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs").c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_ISOLATED, nullptr, nullptr);
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_ISOLATED,
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(ns2 != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns2, nullptr, shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
// This should not have affect search path for default namespace:
ASSERT_TRUE(dlopen(root_lib, RTLD_NOW) == nullptr);
@ -725,6 +738,16 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_smoke) {
ASSERT_TRUE(ns_get_dlopened_string1() != ns_get_dlopened_string2());
// Check that symbols from non-shared libraries a shared library depends on are not visible
// from original namespace.
fn_t ns_get_internal_extern_string =
reinterpret_cast<fn_t>(dlsym(handle1, "ns_get_internal_extern_string"));
ASSERT_TRUE(ns_get_internal_extern_string != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(ns_get_internal_extern_string() == nullptr) <<
"ns_get_internal_extern_string() expected to return null but returns \"" <<
ns_get_internal_extern_string() << "\"";
dlclose(handle1);
// Check if handle2 is still alive (and well)
@ -736,9 +759,187 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_smoke) {
dlclose(handle2);
}
TEST(dlext, ns_symbol_visibilty_one_namespace) {
static const char* root_lib = "libnstest_root.so";
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_anonymous_namespace(g_core_shared_libs.c_str(), nullptr));
const std::string ns_search_path = get_testlib_root() + "/public_namespace_libs:" +
get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs";
android_namespace_t* ns =
android_create_namespace("one",
nullptr,
ns_search_path.c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_ISOLATED,
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns, nullptr, g_core_shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
android_dlextinfo extinfo;
extinfo.flags = ANDROID_DLEXT_USE_NAMESPACE;
extinfo.library_namespace = ns;
void* handle = android_dlopen_ext(root_lib, RTLD_NOW, &extinfo);
ASSERT_TRUE(handle != nullptr) << dlerror();
typedef const char* (*fn_t)();
// Check that relocation worked correctly
fn_t ns_get_internal_extern_string =
reinterpret_cast<fn_t>(dlsym(handle, "ns_get_internal_extern_string"));
ASSERT_TRUE(ns_get_internal_extern_string != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_STREQ("This string is from a library a shared library depends on", ns_get_internal_extern_string());
fn_t internal_extern_string_fn =
reinterpret_cast<fn_t>(dlsym(handle, "internal_extern_string"));
ASSERT_TRUE(internal_extern_string_fn != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_STREQ("This string is from a library a shared library depends on", internal_extern_string_fn());
}
TEST(dlext, ns_symbol_visibilty_between_namespaces) {
static const char* root_lib = "libnstest_root.so";
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_anonymous_namespace(g_core_shared_libs.c_str(), nullptr));
const std::string public_ns_search_path = get_testlib_root() + "/public_namespace_libs";
const std::string private_ns_search_path = get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs";
android_namespace_t* ns_public =
android_create_namespace("public",
nullptr,
public_ns_search_path.c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_ISOLATED,
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns_public, nullptr, g_core_shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
android_namespace_t* ns_private =
android_create_namespace("private",
nullptr,
private_ns_search_path.c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_ISOLATED,
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns_private, ns_public, g_public_lib)) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns_private, nullptr, g_core_shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
android_dlextinfo extinfo;
extinfo.flags = ANDROID_DLEXT_USE_NAMESPACE;
extinfo.library_namespace = ns_private;
void* handle = android_dlopen_ext(root_lib, RTLD_NOW, &extinfo);
ASSERT_TRUE(handle != nullptr) << dlerror();
typedef const char* (*fn_t)();
// Check that relocation worked correctly
fn_t ns_get_internal_extern_string =
reinterpret_cast<fn_t>(dlsym(handle, "ns_get_internal_extern_string"));
ASSERT_TRUE(ns_get_internal_extern_string != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(ns_get_internal_extern_string() == nullptr) <<
"ns_get_internal_extern_string() expected to return null but returns \"" <<
ns_get_internal_extern_string() << "\"";
fn_t internal_extern_string_fn =
reinterpret_cast<fn_t>(dlsym(handle, "internal_extern_string"));
ASSERT_TRUE(internal_extern_string_fn == nullptr);
ASSERT_STREQ("undefined symbol: internal_extern_string", dlerror());
}
TEST(dlext, ns_unload_between_namespaces) {
static const char* root_lib = "libnstest_root.so";
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_anonymous_namespace(g_core_shared_libs.c_str(), nullptr));
const std::string public_ns_search_path = get_testlib_root() + "/public_namespace_libs";
const std::string private_ns_search_path = get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs";
android_namespace_t* ns_public =
android_create_namespace("public",
nullptr,
public_ns_search_path.c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_ISOLATED,
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns_public, nullptr, g_core_shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
android_namespace_t* ns_private =
android_create_namespace("private",
nullptr,
private_ns_search_path.c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_ISOLATED,
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns_private, ns_public, g_public_lib)) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns_private, nullptr, g_core_shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
android_dlextinfo extinfo;
extinfo.flags = ANDROID_DLEXT_USE_NAMESPACE;
extinfo.library_namespace = ns_private;
void* handle = android_dlopen_ext(root_lib, RTLD_NOW, &extinfo);
ASSERT_TRUE(handle != nullptr) << dlerror();
dlclose(handle);
// Check that root_lib was unloaded
handle = android_dlopen_ext(root_lib, RTLD_NOW | RTLD_NOLOAD, &extinfo);
ASSERT_TRUE(handle == nullptr);
ASSERT_EQ(std::string("dlopen failed: library \"") + root_lib +
"\" wasn't loaded and RTLD_NOLOAD prevented it", dlerror());
// Check that shared library was unloaded in public ns
extinfo.library_namespace = ns_public;
handle = android_dlopen_ext(g_public_lib, RTLD_NOW | RTLD_NOLOAD, &extinfo);
ASSERT_TRUE(handle == nullptr);
ASSERT_EQ(std::string("dlopen failed: library \"") + g_public_lib +
"\" wasn't loaded and RTLD_NOLOAD prevented it", dlerror());
}
TEST(dlext, ns_cyclic_namespaces) {
// Test that ns1->ns2->ns1 link does not break the loader
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_anonymous_namespace(g_core_shared_libs.c_str(), nullptr));
std::string shared_libs = g_core_shared_libs + ":libthatdoesnotexist.so";
const std::string ns_search_path = get_testlib_root() + "/public_namespace_libs";
android_namespace_t* ns1 =
android_create_namespace("ns1",
nullptr,
ns_search_path.c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_ISOLATED,
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns1, nullptr, g_core_shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
android_namespace_t* ns2 =
android_create_namespace("ns1",
nullptr,
ns_search_path.c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_ISOLATED,
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns2, nullptr, g_core_shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns2, ns1, shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns1, ns2, shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
android_dlextinfo extinfo;
extinfo.flags = ANDROID_DLEXT_USE_NAMESPACE;
extinfo.library_namespace = ns1;
void* handle = android_dlopen_ext("libthatdoesnotexist.so", RTLD_NOW, &extinfo);
ASSERT_TRUE(handle == nullptr);
ASSERT_STREQ("dlopen failed: library \"libthatdoesnotexist.so\" not found", dlerror());
}
TEST(dlext, ns_isolated) {
static const char* root_lib = "libnstest_root_not_isolated.so";
std::string path = std::string("libc.so:libc++.so:libdl.so:libm.so:") + g_public_lib;
std::string shared_libs = g_core_shared_libs + ":" + g_public_lib;
const std::string lib_public_path = get_testlib_root() + "/public_namespace_libs/" + g_public_lib;
void* handle_public = dlopen(lib_public_path.c_str(), RTLD_NOW);
@ -746,13 +947,17 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_isolated) {
android_set_application_target_sdk_version(42U); // something > 23
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_namespaces(path.c_str(), nullptr)) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_anonymous_namespace(shared_libs.c_str(), nullptr)) << dlerror();
android_namespace_t* ns_not_isolated =
android_create_namespace("private", nullptr,
android_create_namespace("private",
nullptr,
(get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs").c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_REGULAR, nullptr, nullptr);
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_REGULAR,
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(ns_not_isolated != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns_not_isolated, nullptr, shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
android_namespace_t* ns_isolated =
android_create_namespace("private_isolated1",
@ -762,6 +967,7 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_isolated) {
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(ns_isolated != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns_isolated, nullptr, shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
android_namespace_t* ns_isolated2 =
android_create_namespace("private_isolated2",
@ -771,6 +977,7 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_isolated) {
get_testlib_root().c_str(),
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(ns_isolated2 != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns_isolated2, nullptr, shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(dlopen(root_lib, RTLD_NOW) == nullptr);
ASSERT_STREQ("dlopen failed: library \"libnstest_root_not_isolated.so\" not found", dlerror());
@ -844,7 +1051,8 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_isolated) {
TEST(dlext, ns_shared) {
static const char* root_lib = "libnstest_root_not_isolated.so";
static const char* root_lib_isolated = "libnstest_root.so";
std::string path = std::string("libc.so:libc++.so:libdl.so:libm.so:") + g_public_lib;
std::string shared_libs = g_core_shared_libs + ":" + g_public_lib;
const std::string lib_public_path = get_testlib_root() + "/public_namespace_libs/" + g_public_lib;
void* handle_public = dlopen(lib_public_path.c_str(), RTLD_NOW);
@ -852,7 +1060,7 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_shared) {
android_set_application_target_sdk_version(42U); // something > 23
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_namespaces(path.c_str(), nullptr)) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_anonymous_namespace(shared_libs.c_str(), nullptr)) << dlerror();
// preload this library to the default namespace to check if it
// is shared later on.
@ -861,17 +1069,24 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_shared) {
ASSERT_TRUE(handle_dlopened != nullptr) << dlerror();
android_namespace_t* ns_not_isolated =
android_create_namespace("private", nullptr,
android_create_namespace("private",
nullptr,
(get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs").c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_REGULAR, nullptr, nullptr);
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_REGULAR,
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(ns_not_isolated != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns_not_isolated, nullptr, shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
android_namespace_t* ns_isolated_shared =
android_create_namespace("private_isolated_shared", nullptr,
android_create_namespace("private_isolated_shared",
nullptr,
(get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs").c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_ISOLATED | ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_SHARED,
nullptr, nullptr);
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(ns_isolated_shared != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns_isolated_shared, nullptr, shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(dlopen(root_lib, RTLD_NOW) == nullptr);
ASSERT_STREQ("dlopen failed: library \"libnstest_root_not_isolated.so\" not found", dlerror());
@ -959,11 +1174,9 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_shared) {
}
TEST(dlext, ns_shared_dlclose) {
std::string path = "libc.so:libc++.so:libdl.so:libm.so";
android_set_application_target_sdk_version(42U); // something > 23
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_namespaces(path.c_str(), nullptr)) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_anonymous_namespace(g_core_shared_libs.c_str(), nullptr)) << dlerror();
// preload this library to the default namespace to check if it
// is shared later on.
@ -972,11 +1185,14 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_shared_dlclose) {
ASSERT_TRUE(handle_dlopened != nullptr) << dlerror();
android_namespace_t* ns_isolated_shared =
android_create_namespace("private_isolated_shared", nullptr,
android_create_namespace("private_isolated_shared",
nullptr,
(get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs").c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_ISOLATED | ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_SHARED,
nullptr, nullptr);
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(ns_isolated_shared != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns_isolated_shared, nullptr, g_core_shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
// Check if "libnstest_dlopened.so" is loaded (and the same)
android_dlextinfo extinfo;
@ -1022,9 +1238,7 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_shared_dlclose) {
TEST(dlext, ns_isolated_rtld_global) {
static const char* root_lib = "libnstest_root.so";
std::string path = "libc.so:libc++.so:libdl.so:libm.so";
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_namespaces(path.c_str(), nullptr));
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_anonymous_namespace(g_core_shared_libs.c_str(), nullptr));
const std::string lib_public_path = get_testlib_root() + "/public_namespace_libs";
@ -1036,6 +1250,7 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_isolated_rtld_global) {
lib_public_path.c_str(),
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(ns1 != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns1, nullptr, g_core_shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
android_namespace_t* ns2 =
android_create_namespace("isolated2",
@ -1045,6 +1260,7 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_isolated_rtld_global) {
lib_public_path.c_str(),
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(ns2 != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns2, nullptr, g_core_shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
android_dlextinfo extinfo;
extinfo.flags = ANDROID_DLEXT_USE_NAMESPACE;
@ -1057,12 +1273,15 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_isolated_rtld_global) {
ASSERT_TRUE(handle_global != nullptr) << dlerror();
android_namespace_t* ns1_child =
android_create_namespace("isolated1_child",
nullptr,
(get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs").c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_ISOLATED,
nullptr,
ns1);
android_create_namespace("isolated1_child",
nullptr,
(get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs").c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_ISOLATED,
nullptr,
ns1);
ASSERT_TRUE(ns1_child != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns1_child, nullptr, g_core_shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
// Now - only ns1 and ns1 child should be able to dlopen root_lib
// attempt to use ns2 should result in dlerror()
@ -1092,22 +1311,28 @@ TEST(dlext, ns_isolated_rtld_global) {
TEST(dlext, ns_anonymous) {
static const char* root_lib = "libnstest_root.so";
std::string path = std::string("libc.so:libc++.so:libdl.so:libm.so:") + g_public_lib;
std::string shared_libs = g_core_shared_libs + ":" + g_public_lib;
const std::string lib_public_path = get_testlib_root() + "/public_namespace_libs/" + g_public_lib;
void* handle_public = dlopen(lib_public_path.c_str(), RTLD_NOW);
ASSERT_TRUE(handle_public != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_init_namespaces(path.c_str(), (get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs").c_str()))
<< dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(
android_init_anonymous_namespace(shared_libs.c_str(),
(get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs").c_str())
) << dlerror();
android_namespace_t* ns = android_create_namespace(
"private", nullptr,
(get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs").c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_REGULAR, nullptr, nullptr);
android_namespace_t* ns =
android_create_namespace("private",
nullptr,
(get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs").c_str(),
ANDROID_NAMESPACE_TYPE_REGULAR,
nullptr,
nullptr);
ASSERT_TRUE(ns != nullptr) << dlerror();
ASSERT_TRUE(android_link_namespaces(ns, nullptr, shared_libs.c_str())) << dlerror();
std::string private_library_absolute_path = get_testlib_root() + "/private_namespace_libs/" + root_lib;

View file

@ -25,10 +25,13 @@
# 2. Check that public libraries loaded in different namespaces are shared
# between them.
# 3. Check that namespace sticks on dlopen
# 4. Check that having access to shared library (libnstest_public.so)
# does not expose symbols from dependent library (libnstest_public_internal.so)
#
# Dependency tree (visibility)
# libnstest_root.so (this should be local to the namespace)
# +-> libnstest_public.so
# +-> libnstest_public_internal.so
# +-> libnstest_private.so
#
# libnstest_dlopened.so (library in private namespace dlopened from libnstest_root.so)
@ -39,7 +42,13 @@ libnstest_root_relative_install_path := private_namespace_libs
module := libnstest_root
include $(LOCAL_PATH)/Android.build.testlib.target.mk
libnstest_public_internal_src_files := namespaces_public_internal.cpp
module := libnstest_public_internal
libnstest_public_internal_relative_install_path := public_namespace_libs
include $(LOCAL_PATH)/Android.build.testlib.target.mk
libnstest_public_src_files := namespaces_public.cpp
libnstest_public_shared_libraries := libnstest_public_internal
module := libnstest_public
libnstest_public_relative_install_path := public_namespace_libs
include $(LOCAL_PATH)/Android.build.testlib.target.mk

View file

@ -0,0 +1,21 @@
/*
* Copyright (C) 2017 The Android Open Source Project
*
* Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
* you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
* You may obtain a copy of the License at
*
* http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
*
* Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
* distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
* WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
* See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
* limitations under the License.
*/
static const char* g_internal_extern_string = "This string is from a library a shared library depends on";
extern "C" const char* internal_extern_string() {
return g_internal_extern_string;
}

View file

@ -20,6 +20,14 @@ static const char* g_local_string = "This string is local to root library";
extern "C" const char* g_private_extern_string;
extern "C" const char* g_public_extern_string;
// This is resolved only if public library is in the same namespace as
// the root one. It should remain unresolved if looking up for public library
// crosses namespace boundary.
//
// Defined in libnstest_public_internal.so on which libnstest_public.so
// depends on
extern "C" const char* __attribute__((weak)) internal_extern_string();
bool g_dlopened = false;
extern "C" const char* ns_get_local_string() {
@ -34,6 +42,14 @@ extern "C" const char* ns_get_public_extern_string() {
return g_public_extern_string;
}
extern "C" const char* ns_get_internal_extern_string() {
if (internal_extern_string != nullptr) {
return internal_extern_string();
} else {
return nullptr;
}
}
extern "C" const char* ns_get_dlopened_string() {
void* handle = dlopen("libnstest_dlopened.so", RTLD_NOW | RTLD_GLOBAL);
if (handle == nullptr) {