Remove usages of long-form variables

The long-form variables (PRODUCTS.<makefile>.<variable>)
are used to get information about multiple products.
However, they've never really worked correctly, and so
importing multiple products is deprecated behavior.

Remove as many usages of the long-form variables and
multi-product imports as possible.

Bug: 228518445
Test: Manually
Change-Id: I0b67f16360ff8bdcdb39638de739440472bccf76
This commit is contained in:
Cole Faust 2022-04-08 11:12:10 -07:00
parent 7bc6d0e71d
commit 81f1e92ed8
7 changed files with 56 additions and 226 deletions

View file

@ -1235,8 +1235,7 @@ endef
# These goals don't need to collect and include Android.mks/CleanSpec.mks
# in the source tree.
dont_bother_goals := out \
product-graph dump-products
dont_bother_goals := out product-graph
# Make ANDROID Soong config variables visible to Android.mk files, for
# consistency with those defined in BoardConfig.mk files.

View file

@ -1235,18 +1235,14 @@ endef
# See the select-bitness-of-required-modules definition.
# $(1): product makefile
define _product-var
$(call get-product-var,$(1),$(2))
endef
define product-installed-files
$(eval _pif_modules := \
$(call _product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_PACKAGES) \
$(if $(filter eng,$(tags_to_install)),$(call _product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_PACKAGES_ENG)) \
$(if $(filter debug,$(tags_to_install)),$(call _product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_PACKAGES_DEBUG)) \
$(if $(filter tests,$(tags_to_install)),$(call _product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_PACKAGES_TESTS)) \
$(if $(filter asan,$(tags_to_install)),$(call _product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_PACKAGES_DEBUG_ASAN)) \
$(if $(filter java_coverage,$(tags_to_install)),$(call _product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_PACKAGES_DEBUG_JAVA_COVERAGE)) \
$(call get-product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_PACKAGES) \
$(if $(filter eng,$(tags_to_install)),$(call get-product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_PACKAGES_ENG)) \
$(if $(filter debug,$(tags_to_install)),$(call get-product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_PACKAGES_DEBUG)) \
$(if $(filter tests,$(tags_to_install)),$(call get-product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_PACKAGES_TESTS)) \
$(if $(filter asan,$(tags_to_install)),$(call get-product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_PACKAGES_DEBUG_ASAN)) \
$(if $(filter java_coverage,$(tags_to_install)),$(call get-product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_PACKAGES_DEBUG_JAVA_COVERAGE)) \
$(call auto-included-modules) \
) \
$(eval ### Filter out the overridden packages and executables before doing expansion) \
@ -1257,13 +1253,13 @@ define product-installed-files
$(call expand-required-modules,_pif_modules,$(_pif_modules),$(_pif_overrides)) \
$(filter-out $(HOST_OUT_ROOT)/%,$(call module-installed-files, $(_pif_modules))) \
$(call resolve-product-relative-paths,\
$(foreach cf,$(call _product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_COPY_FILES),$(call word-colon,2,$(cf))))
$(foreach cf,$(call get-product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_COPY_FILES),$(call word-colon,2,$(cf))))
endef
# Similar to product-installed-files above, but handles PRODUCT_HOST_PACKAGES instead
# This does support the :32 / :64 syntax, but does not support module overrides.
define host-installed-files
$(eval _hif_modules := $(call _product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_HOST_PACKAGES)) \
$(eval _hif_modules := $(call get-product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_HOST_PACKAGES)) \
$(eval ### Split host vs host cross modules) \
$(eval _hcif_modules := $(filter host_cross_%,$(_hif_modules))) \
$(eval _hif_modules := $(filter-out host_cross_%,$(_hif_modules))) \

View file

@ -25,7 +25,6 @@ PARSE_TIME_MAKE_GOALS := \
cts \
custom_images \
dicttool_aosp \
dump-products \
eng \
oem_image \
online-system-api-sdk-docs \

View file

@ -15,12 +15,12 @@
#
# the sort also acts as a strip to remove the single space entries that creep in because of the evals
define gather-all-products
define gather-all-makefiles-for-current-product
$(eval _all_products_visited := )\
$(sort $(call all-products-inner, $(PRODUCTS)))
$(sort $(call gather-all-makefiles-for-current-product-inner,$(INTERNAL_PRODUCT)))
endef
define all-products-inner
define gather-all-makefiles-for-current-product-inner
$(foreach p,$(1),\
$(if $(filter $(p),$(_all_products_visited)),, \
$(p) \
@ -30,30 +30,12 @@ define all-products-inner
)
endef
this_makefile := build/make/core/product-graph.mk
products_graph := $(OUT_DIR)/products.dot
ifeq ($(strip $(ANDROID_PRODUCT_GRAPH)),)
products_list := $(INTERNAL_PRODUCT)
else
ifeq ($(strip $(ANDROID_PRODUCT_GRAPH)),--all)
products_list := --all
else
products_list := $(foreach prod,$(ANDROID_PRODUCT_GRAPH),$(call resolve-short-product-name,$(prod)))
endif
endif
all_products := $(call gather-all-products)
open_parethesis := (
close_parenthesis := )
node_color_target := orange
node_color_common := beige
node_color_vendor := lavenderblush
node_color_default := white
define node-color
$(if $(filter $(1),$(PRIVATE_PRODUCTS_FILTER)),\
$(if $(filter $(1),$(PRIVATE_TOP_LEVEL_MAKEFILE)),\
$(node_color_target),\
$(if $(filter build/make/target/product/%,$(1)),\
$(node_color_common),\
@ -62,30 +44,33 @@ $(if $(filter $(1),$(PRIVATE_PRODUCTS_FILTER)),\
)
endef
open_parethesis := (
close_parenthesis := )
# Emit properties of a product node to a file.
# $(1) the product
# $(2) the output file
define emit-product-node-props
$(hide) echo \"$(1)\" [ \
label=\"$(dir $(1))\\n$(notdir $(1))\\n\\n$(subst $(close_parenthesis),,$(subst $(open_parethesis),,$(call get-product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_MODEL)))\\n$(call get-product-var,$(1),PRODUCT_DEVICE)\" \
label=\"$(dir $(1))\\n$(notdir $(1))$(if $(filter $(1),$(PRIVATE_TOP_LEVEL_MAKEFILE)),$(subst $(open_parethesis),,$(subst $(close_parenthesis),,\\n\\n$(PRODUCT_MODEL)\\n$(PRODUCT_DEVICE))))\" \
style=\"filled\" fillcolor=\"$(strip $(call node-color,$(1)))\" \
colorscheme=\"svg\" fontcolor=\"darkblue\" \
] >> $(2)
endef
$(products_graph): PRIVATE_PRODUCTS := $(all_products)
$(products_graph): PRIVATE_PRODUCTS_FILTER := $(products_list)
products_graph := $(OUT_DIR)/products.dot
$(products_graph): $(this_makefile)
@echo Product graph DOT: $@ for $(PRIVATE_PRODUCTS_FILTER)
$(hide) echo 'digraph {' > $@.in
$(hide) echo 'graph [ ratio=.5 ];' >> $@.in
$(hide) $(foreach p,$(PRIVATE_PRODUCTS), \
$(foreach d,$(PRODUCTS.$(strip $(p)).INHERITS_FROM), echo \"$(d)\" -\> \"$(p)\" >> $@.in;))
$(foreach p,$(PRIVATE_PRODUCTS),$(call emit-product-node-props,$(p),$@.in))
$(hide) echo '}' >> $@.in
$(hide) build/make/tools/filter-product-graph.py $(PRIVATE_PRODUCTS_FILTER) < $@.in > $@
$(products_graph): PRIVATE_ALL_MAKEFILES_FOR_THIS_PRODUCT := $(call gather-all-makefiles-for-current-product)
$(products_graph): PRIVATE_TOP_LEVEL_MAKEFILE := $(INTERNAL_PRODUCT)
$(products_graph):
@echo Product graph DOT: $@ for $(PRIVATE_TOP_LEVEL_MAKEFILE)
$(hide) echo 'digraph {' > $@
$(hide) echo 'graph [ ratio=.5 ];' >> $@
$(hide) $(foreach p,$(PRIVATE_ALL_MAKEFILES_FOR_THIS_PRODUCT), \
$(foreach d,$(PRODUCTS.$(strip $(p)).INHERITS_FROM), echo \"$(d)\" -\> \"$(p)\" >> $@;))
$(foreach p,$(PRIVATE_ALL_MAKEFILES_FOR_THIS_PRODUCT),$(call emit-product-node-props,$(p),$@))
$(hide) echo '}' >> $@
.PHONY: product-graph
product-graph: $(products_graph)

View file

@ -377,17 +377,6 @@ _product_single_value_vars += PRODUCT_MODULE_BUILD_FROM_SOURCE
.KATI_READONLY := _product_single_value_vars _product_list_vars
_product_var_list :=$= $(_product_single_value_vars) $(_product_list_vars)
define dump-product
$(warning ==== $(1) ====)\
$(foreach v,$(_product_var_list),\
$(warning PRODUCTS.$(1).$(v) := $(call get-product-var,$(1),$(v))))\
$(warning --------)
endef
define dump-products
$(foreach p,$(PRODUCTS),$(call dump-product,$(p)))
endef
#
# Functions for including product makefiles
#
@ -464,64 +453,18 @@ endef
#
# Does various consistency checks on all of the known products.
# Does various consistency checks on the current product.
# Takes no parameters, so $(call ) is not necessary.
#
define check-all-products
define check-current-product
$(if ,, \
$(eval _cap_names :=) \
$(foreach p,$(PRODUCTS), \
$(eval pn := $(strip $(PRODUCTS.$(p).PRODUCT_NAME))) \
$(if $(pn),,$(error $(p): PRODUCT_NAME must be defined.)) \
$(if $(filter $(pn),$(_cap_names)), \
$(error $(p): PRODUCT_NAME must be unique; "$(pn)" already used by $(strip \
$(foreach \
pp,$(PRODUCTS),
$(if $(filter $(pn),$(PRODUCTS.$(pp).PRODUCT_NAME)), \
$(pp) \
))) \
) \
) \
$(eval _cap_names += $(pn)) \
$(if $(call is-c-identifier,$(pn)),, \
$(error $(p): PRODUCT_NAME must be a valid C identifier, not "$(pn)") \
) \
$(eval pb := $(strip $(PRODUCTS.$(p).PRODUCT_BRAND))) \
$(if $(pb),,$(error $(p): PRODUCT_BRAND must be defined.)) \
$(foreach cf,$(strip $(PRODUCTS.$(p).PRODUCT_COPY_FILES)), \
$(if $(filter 2 3,$(words $(subst :,$(space),$(cf)))),, \
$(error $(p): malformed COPY_FILE "$(cf)") \
) \
) \
) \
)
endef
#
# Returns the product makefile path for the product with the provided name
#
# $(1): short product name like "generic"
#
define _resolve-short-product-name
$(eval pn := $(strip $(1)))
$(eval p := \
$(foreach p,$(PRODUCTS), \
$(if $(filter $(pn),$(PRODUCTS.$(p).PRODUCT_NAME)), \
$(p) \
)) \
)
$(eval p := $(sort $(p)))
$(if $(filter 1,$(words $(p))), \
$(p), \
$(if $(filter 0,$(words $(p))), \
$(error No matches for product "$(pn)"), \
$(error Product "$(pn)" ambiguous: matches $(p)) \
) \
)
endef
define resolve-short-product-name
$(strip $(call _resolve-short-product-name,$(1)))
$(if $(call is-c-identifier,$(PRODUCT_NAME)),, \
$(error $(INTERNAL_PRODUCT): PRODUCT_NAME must be a valid C identifier, not "$(pn)")) \
$(if $(PRODUCT_BRAND),, \
$(error $(INTERNAL_PRODUCT): PRODUCT_BRAND must be defined.)) \
$(foreach cf,$(strip $(PRODUCT_COPY_FILES)), \
$(if $(filter 2 3,$(words $(subst :,$(space),$(cf)))),, \
$(error $(p): malformed COPY_FILE "$(cf)"))))
endef
# BoardConfig variables that are also inherited in product mks. Should ideally

View file

@ -208,35 +208,26 @@ $(foreach f,$(android_products_makefiles), \
)
# Dedup, extract product names, etc.
product_paths :=$(sort $(product_paths))
all_named_products := $(call _first,$(product_paths),:)
all_product_makefiles := $(call _second,$(product_paths),:)
product_paths := $(sort $(product_paths))
all_named_products := $(sort $(call _first,$(product_paths),:))
all_product_makefiles := $(sort $(call _second,$(product_paths),:))
current_product_makefile := $(call _second,$(filter $(TARGET_PRODUCT):%,$(product_paths)),:)
COMMON_LUNCH_CHOICES := $(sort $(common_lunch_choices))
load_all_product_makefiles :=
ifneq (,$(filter product-graph, $(MAKECMDGOALS)))
ifeq ($(ANDROID_PRODUCT_GRAPH),--all)
load_all_product_makefiles := true
endif
endif
ifneq (,$(filter dump-products,$(MAKECMDGOALS)))
ifeq ($(ANDROID_DUMP_PRODUCTS),all)
load_all_product_makefiles := true
endif
endif
# Check that there are no duplicate product names
$(foreach p,$(all_named_products), \
$(if $(filter 1,$(words $(filter $(p):%,$(product_paths)))),, \
$(error Product name must be unique, "$(p)" used by $(call _second,$(filter $(p):%,$(product_paths)),:))))
ifneq ($(ALLOW_RULES_IN_PRODUCT_CONFIG),)
_product_config_saved_KATI_ALLOW_RULES := $(.KATI_ALLOW_RULES)
.KATI_ALLOW_RULES := $(ALLOW_RULES_IN_PRODUCT_CONFIG)
endif
ifeq ($(load_all_product_makefiles),true)
# Import all product makefiles.
$(call import-products, $(all_product_makefiles))
else
# Import just the current product.
$(if $(current_product_makefile),,$(error Can not locate config makefile for product "$(TARGET_PRODUCT)"))
ifeq (,$(current_product_makefile))
$(error Can not locate config makefile for product "$(TARGET_PRODUCT)")
endif
ifneq (,$(filter $(TARGET_PRODUCT),$(products_using_starlark_config)))
RBC_PRODUCT_CONFIG := true
RBC_BOARD_CONFIG := true
@ -258,44 +249,29 @@ else
endif
include $(OUT_DIR)/rbc/rbc_product_config_results.mk
endif
endif # Import all or just the current product makefile
# Quick check
$(check-all-products)
# This step was already handled in the RBC product configuration.
# Since the equivalent starlark code will not add the partial products to
# the PRODUCTS variable, it's ok for them to be set before check-all-products
ifeq ($(RBC_PRODUCT_CONFIG)$(SKIP_ARTIFACT_PATH_REQUIREMENT_PRODUCTS_CHECK),)
# Import all the products that have made artifact path requirements, so that we can verify
# the artifacts they produce.
# These are imported after check-all-products because some of them might not be real products.
# the artifacts they produce. They might be intermediate makefiles instead of real products.
$(foreach makefile,$(ARTIFACT_PATH_REQUIREMENT_PRODUCTS),\
$(if $(filter-out $(makefile),$(PRODUCTS)),$(eval $(call import-products,$(makefile))))\
)
endif
INTERNAL_PRODUCT := $(current_product_makefile)
# Strip and assign the PRODUCT_ variables.
$(call strip-product-vars)
# Quick check
$(check-current-product)
ifneq ($(ALLOW_RULES_IN_PRODUCT_CONFIG),)
.KATI_ALLOW_RULES := $(_saved_KATI_ALLOW_RULES)
_product_config_saved_KATI_ALLOW_RULES :=
endif
ifneq ($(filter dump-products, $(MAKECMDGOALS)),)
$(dump-products)
endif
# Convert a short name like "sooner" into the path to the product
# file defining that product.
#
INTERNAL_PRODUCT := $(call resolve-short-product-name, $(TARGET_PRODUCT))
ifneq ($(current_product_makefile),$(INTERNAL_PRODUCT))
$(error PRODUCT_NAME inconsistent in $(current_product_makefile) and $(INTERNAL_PRODUCT))
endif
############################################################################
# Strip and assign the PRODUCT_ variables.
$(call strip-product-vars)
current_product_makefile :=
all_product_makefiles :=

View file

@ -1,68 +0,0 @@
#!/usr/bin/env python
# vim: ts=2 sw=2 nocindent
import re
import sys
def choose_regex(regs, line):
for func,reg in regs:
m = reg.match(line)
if m:
return (func,m)
return (None,None)
def gather(included, deps):
result = set()
for inc in included:
result.add(inc)
for d in deps:
if inc == d[1]:
result.add(d[0])
return result
def main():
deps = []
infos = []
def dependency(m):
deps.append((m.group(1), m.group(2)))
def info(m):
infos.append((m.group(1), m.group(2)))
REGS = [
(dependency, re.compile(r'"(.*)"\s*->\s*"(.*)"')),
(info, re.compile(r'"(.*)"(\s*\[.*\])')),
]
lines = sys.stdin.readlines()
lines = [line.strip() for line in lines]
for line in lines:
func,m = choose_regex(REGS, line)
if func:
func(m)
# filter
sys.stderr.write("argv: " + str(sys.argv) + "\n")
if not (len(sys.argv) == 2 and sys.argv[1] == "--all"):
targets = sys.argv[1:]
included = set(targets)
prevLen = -1
while prevLen != len(included):
prevLen = len(included)
included = gather(included, deps)
deps = [dep for dep in deps if dep[1] in included]
infos = [info for info in infos if info[0] in included]
print "digraph {"
print "graph [ ratio=.5 ];"
for dep in deps:
print '"%s" -> "%s"' % dep
for info in infos:
print '"%s"%s' % info
print "}"
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()