Merge "Allow implementation details to be excluded from signature patterns file"

This commit is contained in:
Paul Duffin 2021-10-06 12:19:23 +00:00 committed by Gerrit Code Review
commit 6546573ec9
4 changed files with 307 additions and 39 deletions

View file

@ -139,6 +139,74 @@ type bootclasspathFragmentProperties struct {
BootclasspathFragmentsDepsProperties
}
type SourceOnlyBootclasspathProperties struct {
Hidden_api struct {
// Contains prefixes of a package hierarchy that is provided solely by this
// bootclasspath_fragment.
//
// This affects the signature patterns file that is used to select the subset of monolithic
// hidden API flags. See split_packages property for more details.
Package_prefixes []string
// The list of split packages provided by this bootclasspath_fragment.
//
// A split package is one that contains classes which are provided by multiple
// bootclasspath_fragment modules.
//
// This defaults to "*" - which treats all packages as being split. A module that has no split
// packages must specify an empty list.
//
// This affects the signature patterns file that is generated by a bootclasspath_fragment and
// used to select the subset of monolithic hidden API flags against which the flags generated
// by the bootclasspath_fragment are compared.
//
// The signature patterns file selects the subset of monolithic hidden API flags using a number
// of patterns, i.e.:
// * The qualified name (including package) of an outermost class, e.g. java/lang/Character.
// This selects all the flags for all the members of this class and any nested classes.
// * A package wildcard, e.g. java/lang/*. This selects all the flags for all the members of all
// the classes in this package (but not in sub-packages).
// * A recursive package wildcard, e.g. java/**. This selects all the flags for all the members
// of all the classes in this package and sub-packages.
//
// The signature patterns file is constructed as follows:
// * All the signatures are retrieved from the all-flags.csv file.
// * The member and inner class names are removed.
// * If a class is in a split package then that is kept, otherwise the class part is removed
// and replaced with a wildcard, i.e. *.
// * If a package matches a package prefix then the package is removed.
// * All the package prefixes are added with a recursive wildcard appended to each, i.e. **.
// * The resulting patterns are sorted.
//
// So, by default (i.e. without specifying any package_prefixes or split_packages) the signature
// patterns is a list of class names, because there are no package packages and all packages are
// assumed to be split.
//
// If any split packages are specified then only those packages are treated as split and all
// other packages are treated as belonging solely to the bootclasspath_fragment and so they use
// wildcard package patterns.
//
// So, if an empty list of split packages is specified then the signature patterns file just
// includes a wildcard package pattern for every package provided by the bootclasspath_fragment.
//
// If split_packages are specified and a package that is split is not listed then it could lead
// to build failures as it will select monolithic flags that are generated by another
// bootclasspath_fragment to compare against the flags provided by this fragment. The latter
// will obviously not contain those flags and that can cause the comparison and build to fail.
//
// If any package prefixes are specified then any matching packages are removed from the
// signature patterns and replaced with a single recursive package pattern.
//
// It is not strictly necessary to specify either package_prefixes or split_packages as the
// defaults will produce a valid set of signature patterns. However, those patterns may include
// implementation details, e.g. names of implementation classes or packages, which will be
// exported to the sdk snapshot in the signature patterns file. That is something that should be
// avoided where possible. Specifying package_prefixes and split_packages allows those
// implementation details to be excluded from the snapshot.
Split_packages []string
}
}
type BootclasspathFragmentModule struct {
android.ModuleBase
android.ApexModuleBase
@ -147,6 +215,8 @@ type BootclasspathFragmentModule struct {
properties bootclasspathFragmentProperties
sourceOnlyProperties SourceOnlyBootclasspathProperties
// Collect the module directory for IDE info in java/jdeps.go.
modulePaths []string
}
@ -180,7 +250,7 @@ type bootImageFilesByArch map[android.ArchType]android.Paths
func bootclasspathFragmentFactory() android.Module {
m := &BootclasspathFragmentModule{}
m.AddProperties(&m.properties)
m.AddProperties(&m.properties, &m.sourceOnlyProperties)
android.InitApexModule(m)
android.InitSdkAwareModule(m)
initClasspathFragment(m, BOOTCLASSPATH)
@ -590,7 +660,7 @@ func (b *BootclasspathFragmentModule) generateHiddenAPIBuildActions(ctx android.
// TODO(b/192868581): Remove once the source and prebuilts provide a signature patterns file of
// their own.
if output.SignaturePatternsPath == nil {
output.SignaturePatternsPath = buildRuleSignaturePatternsFile(ctx, output.AllFlagsPath)
output.SignaturePatternsPath = buildRuleSignaturePatternsFile(ctx, output.AllFlagsPath, []string{"*"}, nil)
}
// Initialize a HiddenAPIInfo structure.
@ -659,7 +729,20 @@ func (b *BootclasspathFragmentModule) createHiddenAPIFlagInput(ctx android.Modul
func (b *BootclasspathFragmentModule) produceHiddenAPIOutput(ctx android.ModuleContext, contents []android.Module, input HiddenAPIFlagInput) *HiddenAPIOutput {
// Generate the rules to create the hidden API flags and update the supplied hiddenAPIInfo with the
// paths to the created files.
return hiddenAPIRulesForBootclasspathFragment(ctx, contents, input)
output := hiddenAPIRulesForBootclasspathFragment(ctx, contents, input)
// If the module specifies split_packages or package_prefixes then use those to generate the
// signature patterns.
splitPackages := b.sourceOnlyProperties.Hidden_api.Split_packages
packagePrefixes := b.sourceOnlyProperties.Hidden_api.Package_prefixes
if splitPackages != nil || packagePrefixes != nil {
if splitPackages == nil {
splitPackages = []string{"*"}
}
output.SignaturePatternsPath = buildRuleSignaturePatternsFile(ctx, output.AllFlagsPath, splitPackages, packagePrefixes)
}
return output
}
// produceBootImageFiles builds the boot image files from the source if it is required.

View file

@ -943,13 +943,22 @@ func (s SignatureCsvSubsets) RelativeToTop() []string {
// buildRuleSignaturePatternsFile creates a rule to generate a file containing the set of signature
// patterns that will select a subset of the monolithic flags.
func buildRuleSignaturePatternsFile(ctx android.ModuleContext, flagsPath android.Path) android.Path {
func buildRuleSignaturePatternsFile(ctx android.ModuleContext, flagsPath android.Path, splitPackages []string, packagePrefixes []string) android.Path {
patternsFile := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, "modular-hiddenapi", "signature-patterns.csv")
// Create a rule to validate the output from the following rule.
rule := android.NewRuleBuilder(pctx, ctx)
// Quote any * in the packages to avoid them being expanded by the shell.
quotedSplitPackages := []string{}
for _, pkg := range splitPackages {
quotedSplitPackages = append(quotedSplitPackages, strings.ReplaceAll(pkg, "*", "\\*"))
}
rule.Command().
BuiltTool("signature_patterns").
FlagWithInput("--flags ", flagsPath).
FlagForEachArg("--split-package ", quotedSplitPackages).
FlagForEachArg("--package-prefix ", packagePrefixes).
FlagWithOutput("--output ", patternsFile)
rule.Build("hiddenAPISignaturePatterns", "hidden API signature patterns")

View file

@ -13,8 +13,10 @@
# WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
# See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
# limitations under the License.
"""Generate a set of signature patterns from the modular flags generated by a
bootclasspath_fragment that can be used to select a subset of monolithic flags
"""Generate a set of signature patterns for a bootclasspath_fragment.
The patterns are generated from the modular flags produced by the
bootclasspath_fragment and are used to select a subset of the monolithic flags
against which the modular flags can be compared.
"""
@ -22,33 +24,122 @@ import argparse
import csv
import sys
def dict_reader(csvfile):
return csv.DictReader(
csvfile, delimiter=',', quotechar='|', fieldnames=['signature']
)
csvfile, delimiter=',', quotechar='|', fieldnames=['signature'])
def produce_patterns_from_file(file):
def dotPackageToSlashPackage(pkg):
return pkg.replace('.', '/')
def slashPackageToDotPackage(pkg):
return pkg.replace('/', '.')
def isSplitPackage(splitPackages, pkg):
return splitPackages and (pkg in splitPackages or '*' in splitPackages)
def matchedByPackagePrefixPattern(packagePrefixes, prefix):
for packagePrefix in packagePrefixes:
if prefix == packagePrefix:
return packagePrefix
elif prefix.startswith(packagePrefix) and prefix[len(
packagePrefix)] == '/':
return packagePrefix
return False
def validate_package_prefixes(splitPackages, packagePrefixes):
# If there are no package prefixes then there is no possible conflict
# between them and the split packages.
if len(packagePrefixes) == 0:
return
# Check to make sure that the split packages and package prefixes do not
# overlap.
errors = []
for splitPackage in splitPackages:
if splitPackage == '*':
# A package prefix matches a split package.
packagePrefixesForOutput = ', '.join(
map(slashPackageToDotPackage, packagePrefixes))
errors.append(
'split package "*" conflicts with all package prefixes %s\n'
' add split_packages:[] to fix' % packagePrefixesForOutput)
else:
packagePrefix = matchedByPackagePrefixPattern(
packagePrefixes, splitPackage)
if packagePrefix:
# A package prefix matches a split package.
splitPackageForOutput = slashPackageToDotPackage(splitPackage)
packagePrefixForOutput = slashPackageToDotPackage(packagePrefix)
errors.append(
'split package %s is matched by package prefix %s' %
(splitPackageForOutput, packagePrefixForOutput))
return errors
def validate_split_packages(splitPackages):
errors = []
if '*' in splitPackages and len(splitPackages) > 1:
errors.append('split packages are invalid as they contain both the'
' wildcard (*) and specific packages, use the wildcard or'
' specific packages, not a mixture')
return errors
def produce_patterns_from_file(file, splitPackages=None, packagePrefixes=None):
with open(file, 'r') as f:
return produce_patterns_from_stream(f)
return produce_patterns_from_stream(f, splitPackages, packagePrefixes)
def produce_patterns_from_stream(stream):
# Read in all the signatures into a list and remove member names.
def produce_patterns_from_stream(stream,
splitPackages=None,
packagePrefixes=None):
splitPackages = set(splitPackages or [])
packagePrefixes = list(packagePrefixes or [])
# Read in all the signatures into a list and remove any unnecessary class
# and member names.
patterns = set()
for row in dict_reader(stream):
signature = row['signature']
text = signature.removeprefix("L")
text = signature.removeprefix('L')
# Remove the class specific member signature
pieces = text.split(";->")
pieces = text.split(';->')
qualifiedClassName = pieces[0]
# Remove inner class names as they cannot be separated
# from the containing outer class.
pieces = qualifiedClassName.split("$", maxsplit=1)
pattern = pieces[0]
pieces = qualifiedClassName.rsplit('/', maxsplit=1)
pkg = pieces[0]
# If the package is split across multiple modules then it cannot be used
# to select the subset of the monolithic flags that this module
# produces. In that case we need to keep the name of the class but can
# discard any nested class names as an outer class cannot be split
# across modules.
#
# If the package is not split then every class in the package must be
# provided by this module so there is no need to list the classes
# explicitly so just use the package name instead.
if isSplitPackage(splitPackages, pkg):
# Remove inner class names.
pieces = qualifiedClassName.split('$', maxsplit=1)
pattern = pieces[0]
else:
# Add a * to ensure that the pattern matches the classes in that
# package.
pattern = pkg + '/*'
patterns.add(pattern)
patterns = list(patterns) #pylint: disable=redefined-variable-type
# Remove any patterns that would be matched by a package prefix pattern.
patterns = list(
filter(lambda p: not matchedByPackagePrefixPattern(packagePrefixes, p),
patterns))
# Add the package prefix patterns to the list. Add a ** to ensure that each
# package prefix pattern will match the classes in that package and all
# sub-packages.
patterns = patterns + list(map(lambda x: x + '/**', packagePrefixes))
# Sort the patterns.
patterns.sort()
return patterns
@ -56,24 +147,47 @@ def produce_patterns_from_stream(stream):
def main(args):
args_parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(
description='Generate a set of signature patterns '
'that select a subset of monolithic hidden API files.'
)
'that select a subset of monolithic hidden API files.')
args_parser.add_argument(
'--flags',
help='The stub flags file which contains an entry for every dex member',
)
args_parser.add_argument(
'--split-package',
action='append',
help='A package that is split across multiple bootclasspath_fragment modules'
)
args_parser.add_argument(
'--package-prefix',
action='append',
help='A package prefix unique to this set of flags')
args_parser.add_argument('--output', help='Generated signature prefixes')
args = args_parser.parse_args(args)
splitPackages = set(map(dotPackageToSlashPackage, args.split_package or []))
errors = validate_split_packages(splitPackages)
packagePrefixes = list(
map(dotPackageToSlashPackage, args.package_prefix or []))
if not errors:
errors = validate_package_prefixes(splitPackages, packagePrefixes)
if errors:
for error in errors:
print(error)
sys.exit(1)
# Read in all the patterns into a list.
patterns = produce_patterns_from_file(args.flags)
patterns = produce_patterns_from_file(args.flags, splitPackages,
packagePrefixes)
# Write out all the patterns.
with open(args.output, 'w') as outputFile:
for pattern in patterns:
outputFile.write(pattern)
outputFile.write("\n")
outputFile.write('\n')
if __name__ == "__main__":
if __name__ == '__main__':
main(sys.argv[1:])

View file

@ -13,37 +13,99 @@
# WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
# See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
# limitations under the License.
"""Unit tests for signature_patterns.py."""
import io
import unittest
from signature_patterns import * #pylint: disable=unused-wildcard-import,wildcard-import
from signature_patterns import * #pylint: disable=unused-wildcard-import,wildcard-import
class TestGeneratedPatterns(unittest.TestCase):
def produce_patterns_from_string(self, csvdata):
with io.StringIO(csvdata) as f:
return produce_patterns_from_stream(f)
def test_generate(self):
#pylint: disable=line-too-long
patterns = self.produce_patterns_from_string(
'''
csvFlags = """
Ljava/lang/ProcessBuilder$Redirect$1;-><init>()V,blocked
Ljava/lang/Character$UnicodeScript;->of(I)Ljava/lang/Character$UnicodeScript;,public-api
Ljava/lang/Object;->hashCode()I,public-api,system-api,test-api
Ljava/lang/Object;->toString()Ljava/lang/String;,blocked
'''
)
#pylint: enable=line-too-long
"""
def produce_patterns_from_string(self,
csv,
splitPackages=None,
packagePrefixes=None):
with io.StringIO(csv) as f:
return produce_patterns_from_stream(f, splitPackages,
packagePrefixes)
def test_generate_default(self):
patterns = self.produce_patterns_from_string(
TestGeneratedPatterns.csvFlags)
expected = [
"java/lang/Character",
"java/lang/Object",
"java/lang/ProcessBuilder",
'java/lang/*',
]
self.assertEqual(expected, patterns)
def test_generate_split_package(self):
patterns = self.produce_patterns_from_string(
TestGeneratedPatterns.csvFlags, splitPackages={'java/lang'})
expected = [
'java/lang/Character',
'java/lang/Object',
'java/lang/ProcessBuilder',
]
self.assertEqual(expected, patterns)
def test_generate_split_package_wildcard(self):
patterns = self.produce_patterns_from_string(
TestGeneratedPatterns.csvFlags, splitPackages={'*'})
expected = [
'java/lang/Character',
'java/lang/Object',
'java/lang/ProcessBuilder',
]
self.assertEqual(expected, patterns)
def test_generate_package_prefix(self):
patterns = self.produce_patterns_from_string(
TestGeneratedPatterns.csvFlags, packagePrefixes={'java/lang'})
expected = [
'java/lang/**',
]
self.assertEqual(expected, patterns)
def test_generate_package_prefix_top_package(self):
patterns = self.produce_patterns_from_string(
TestGeneratedPatterns.csvFlags, packagePrefixes={'java'})
expected = [
'java/**',
]
self.assertEqual(expected, patterns)
def test_split_package_wildcard_conflicts_with_other_split_packages(self):
errors = validate_split_packages({'*', 'java'})
expected = [
'split packages are invalid as they contain both the wildcard (*)'
' and specific packages, use the wildcard or specific packages,'
' not a mixture'
]
self.assertEqual(expected, errors)
def test_split_package_wildcard_conflicts_with_package_prefixes(self):
errors = validate_package_prefixes({'*'}, packagePrefixes={'java'})
expected = [
'split package "*" conflicts with all package prefixes java\n'
' add split_packages:[] to fix',
]
self.assertEqual(expected, errors)
def test_split_package_conflict(self):
errors = validate_package_prefixes({'java/split'},
packagePrefixes={'java'})
expected = [
'split package java.split is matched by package prefix java',
]
self.assertEqual(expected, errors)
if __name__ == '__main__':
unittest.main(verbosity=2)