platform_build_soong/apex/builder.go

// Copyright (C) 2019 The Android Open Source Project
//
// Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
// you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
// You may obtain a copy of the License at
//
//     http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
//
// Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
// distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
// WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
// See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
// limitations under the License.

package apex

import (
	"encoding/json"
	"fmt"
	"path/filepath"
	"runtime"
	"sort"
	"strconv"
	"strings"

	"android/soong/android"
	"android/soong/java"

	"github.com/google/blueprint"
	"github.com/google/blueprint/proptools"
)

var (
	pctx = android.NewPackageContext("android/apex")
)

func init() {
	pctx.Import("android/soong/android")
	pctx.Import("android/soong/cc/config")
	pctx.Import("android/soong/java")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("apexer", "apexer")
	// ART minimal builds (using the master-art manifest) do not have the "frameworks/base"
	// projects, and hence cannot build 'aapt2'. Use the SDK prebuilt instead.
	hostBinToolVariableWithPrebuilt := func(name, prebuiltDir, tool string) {
		pctx.VariableFunc(name, func(ctx android.PackageVarContext) string {
			if !ctx.Config().FrameworksBaseDirExists(ctx) {
				return filepath.Join(prebuiltDir, runtime.GOOS, "bin", tool)
			} else {
				return ctx.Config().HostToolPath(ctx, tool).String()
			}
		})
	}
	hostBinToolVariableWithPrebuilt("aapt2", "prebuilts/sdk/tools", "aapt2")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("avbtool", "avbtool")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("e2fsdroid", "e2fsdroid")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("merge_zips", "merge_zips")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("mke2fs", "mke2fs")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("resize2fs", "resize2fs")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("sefcontext_compile", "sefcontext_compile")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("soong_zip", "soong_zip")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("zip2zip", "zip2zip")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("zipalign", "zipalign")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("jsonmodify", "jsonmodify")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("conv_apex_manifest", "conv_apex_manifest")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("extract_apks", "extract_apks")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("make_f2fs", "make_f2fs")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("sload_f2fs", "sload_f2fs")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("make_erofs", "make_erofs")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("apex_compression_tool", "apex_compression_tool")
	pctx.HostBinToolVariable("dexdeps", "dexdeps")
	pctx.SourcePathVariable("genNdkUsedbyApexPath", "build/soong/scripts/gen_ndk_usedby_apex.sh")
}

var (
	apexManifestRule = pctx.StaticRule("apexManifestRule", blueprint.RuleParams{
		Command: `rm -f $out && ${jsonmodify} $in ` +
			`-a provideNativeLibs ${provideNativeLibs} ` +
			`-a requireNativeLibs ${requireNativeLibs} ` +
			`${opt} ` +
			`-o $out`,
		CommandDeps: []string{"${jsonmodify}"},
		Description: "prepare ${out}",
	}, "provideNativeLibs", "requireNativeLibs", "opt")

	stripApexManifestRule = pctx.StaticRule("stripApexManifestRule", blueprint.RuleParams{
		Command:     `rm -f $out && ${conv_apex_manifest} strip $in -o $out`,
		CommandDeps: []string{"${conv_apex_manifest}"},
		Description: "strip ${in}=>${out}",
	})

	pbApexManifestRule = pctx.StaticRule("pbApexManifestRule", blueprint.RuleParams{
		Command:     `rm -f $out && ${conv_apex_manifest} proto $in -o $out`,
		CommandDeps: []string{"${conv_apex_manifest}"},
		Description: "convert ${in}=>${out}",
	})

	// TODO(b/113233103): make sure that file_contexts is as expected, i.e., validate
	// against the binary policy using sefcontext_compiler -p <policy>.

	// TODO(b/114327326): automate the generation of file_contexts
	apexRule = pctx.StaticRule("apexRule", blueprint.RuleParams{
		Command: `rm -rf ${image_dir} && mkdir -p ${image_dir} && ` +
			`(. ${out}.copy_commands) && ` +
			`APEXER_TOOL_PATH=${tool_path} ` +
			`${apexer} --force --manifest ${manifest} ` +
			`--file_contexts ${file_contexts} ` +
			`--canned_fs_config ${canned_fs_config} ` +
			`--include_build_info ` +
			`--payload_type image ` +
			`--key ${key} ${opt_flags} ${image_dir} ${out} `,
		CommandDeps: []string{"${apexer}", "${avbtool}", "${e2fsdroid}", "${merge_zips}",
			"${mke2fs}", "${resize2fs}", "${sefcontext_compile}", "${make_f2fs}", "${sload_f2fs}", "${make_erofs}",
			"${soong_zip}", "${zipalign}", "${aapt2}", "prebuilts/sdk/current/public/android.jar"},
		Rspfile:        "${out}.copy_commands",
		RspfileContent: "${copy_commands}",
		Description:    "APEX ${image_dir} => ${out}",
	}, "tool_path", "image_dir", "copy_commands", "file_contexts", "canned_fs_config", "key", "opt_flags", "manifest", "payload_fs_type")

	zipApexRule = pctx.StaticRule("zipApexRule", blueprint.RuleParams{
		Command: `rm -rf ${image_dir} && mkdir -p ${image_dir} && ` +
			`(. ${out}.copy_commands) && ` +
			`APEXER_TOOL_PATH=${tool_path} ` +
			`${apexer} --force --manifest ${manifest} ` +
			`--payload_type zip ` +
			`${image_dir} ${out} `,
		CommandDeps:    []string{"${apexer}", "${merge_zips}", "${soong_zip}", "${zipalign}", "${aapt2}"},
		Rspfile:        "${out}.copy_commands",
		RspfileContent: "${copy_commands}",
		Description:    "ZipAPEX ${image_dir} => ${out}",
	}, "tool_path", "image_dir", "copy_commands", "manifest")

	apexProtoConvertRule = pctx.AndroidStaticRule("apexProtoConvertRule",
		blueprint.RuleParams{
			Command:     `${aapt2} convert --output-format proto $in -o $out`,
			CommandDeps: []string{"${aapt2}"},
		})

	apexBundleRule = pctx.StaticRule("apexBundleRule", blueprint.RuleParams{
		Command: `${zip2zip} -i $in -o $out.base ` +
			`apex_payload.img:apex/${abi}.img ` +
			`apex_build_info.pb:apex/${abi}.build_info.pb ` +
			`apex_manifest.json:root/apex_manifest.json ` +
			`apex_manifest.pb:root/apex_manifest.pb ` +
			`AndroidManifest.xml:manifest/AndroidManifest.xml ` +
			`assets/NOTICE.html.gz:assets/NOTICE.html.gz &&` +
			`${soong_zip} -o $out.config -C $$(dirname ${config}) -f ${config} && ` +
			`${merge_zips} $out $out.base $out.config`,
		CommandDeps: []string{"${zip2zip}", "${soong_zip}", "${merge_zips}"},
		Description: "app bundle",
	}, "abi", "config")

	emitApexContentRule = pctx.StaticRule("emitApexContentRule", blueprint.RuleParams{
		Command:        `rm -f ${out} && touch ${out} && (. ${out}.emit_commands)`,
		Rspfile:        "${out}.emit_commands",
		RspfileContent: "${emit_commands}",
		Description:    "Emit APEX image content",
	}, "emit_commands")

	diffApexContentRule = pctx.StaticRule("diffApexContentRule", blueprint.RuleParams{
		Command: `diff --unchanged-group-format='' \` +
			`--changed-group-format='%<' \` +
			`${image_content_file} ${allowed_files_file} || (` +
			`echo -e "New unexpected files were added to ${apex_module_name}." ` +
			` "To fix the build run following command:" && ` +
			`echo "system/apex/tools/update_allowed_list.sh ${allowed_files_file} ${image_content_file}" && ` +
			`exit 1); touch ${out}`,
		Description: "Diff ${image_content_file} and ${allowed_files_file}",
	}, "image_content_file", "allowed_files_file", "apex_module_name")

	generateAPIsUsedbyApexRule = pctx.StaticRule("generateAPIsUsedbyApexRule", blueprint.RuleParams{
		Command:     "$genNdkUsedbyApexPath ${image_dir} ${readelf} ${out}",
		CommandDeps: []string{"${genNdkUsedbyApexPath}"},
		Description: "Generate symbol list used by Apex",
	}, "image_dir", "readelf")

	// Don't add more rules here. Consider using android.NewRuleBuilder instead.
)

// buildManifest creates buile rules to modify the input apex_manifest.json to add information
// gathered by the build system such as provided/required native libraries. Two output files having
// different formats are generated. a.manifestJsonOut is JSON format for Q devices, and
// a.manifest.PbOut is protobuf format for R+ devices.
// TODO(jiyong): make this to return paths instead of directly storing the paths to apexBundle
func (a *apexBundle) buildManifest(ctx android.ModuleContext, provideNativeLibs, requireNativeLibs []string) {
	src := android.PathForModuleSrc(ctx, proptools.StringDefault(a.properties.Manifest, "apex_manifest.json"))

	// Put dependency({provide|require}NativeLibs) in apex_manifest.json
	provideNativeLibs = android.SortedUniqueStrings(provideNativeLibs)
	requireNativeLibs = android.SortedUniqueStrings(android.RemoveListFromList(requireNativeLibs, provideNativeLibs))

	// APEX name can be overridden
	optCommands := []string{}
	if a.properties.Apex_name != nil {
		optCommands = append(optCommands, "-v name "+*a.properties.Apex_name)
	}

	// Collect jniLibs. Notice that a.filesInfo is already sorted
	var jniLibs []string
	for _, fi := range a.filesInfo {
		if fi.isJniLib && !android.InList(fi.stem(), jniLibs) {
			jniLibs = append(jniLibs, fi.stem())
		}
	}
	if len(jniLibs) > 0 {
		optCommands = append(optCommands, "-a jniLibs "+strings.Join(jniLibs, " "))
	}

	manifestJsonFullOut := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, "apex_manifest_full.json")
	ctx.Build(pctx, android.BuildParams{
		Rule:   apexManifestRule,
		Input:  src,
		Output: manifestJsonFullOut,
		Args: map[string]string{
			"provideNativeLibs": strings.Join(provideNativeLibs, " "),
			"requireNativeLibs": strings.Join(requireNativeLibs, " "),
			"opt":               strings.Join(optCommands, " "),
		},
	})

	// b/143654022 Q apexd can't understand newly added keys in apex_manifest.json prepare
	// stripped-down version so that APEX modules built from R+ can be installed to Q
	minSdkVersion := a.minSdkVersion(ctx)
	if minSdkVersion.EqualTo(android.SdkVersion_Android10) {
		a.manifestJsonOut = android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, "apex_manifest.json")
		ctx.Build(pctx, android.BuildParams{
			Rule:   stripApexManifestRule,
			Input:  manifestJsonFullOut,
			Output: a.manifestJsonOut,
		})
	}

	// From R+, protobuf binary format (.pb) is the standard format for apex_manifest
	a.manifestPbOut = android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, "apex_manifest.pb")
	ctx.Build(pctx, android.BuildParams{
		Rule:   pbApexManifestRule,
		Input:  manifestJsonFullOut,
		Output: a.manifestPbOut,
	})
}

// buildFileContexts create build rules to append an entry for apex_manifest.pb to the file_contexts
// file for this APEX which is either from /systme/sepolicy/apex/<apexname>-file_contexts or from
// the file_contexts property of this APEX. This is to make sure that the manifest file is correctly
// labeled as system_file.
func (a *apexBundle) buildFileContexts(ctx android.ModuleContext) android.OutputPath {
	var fileContexts android.Path
	var fileContextsDir string
	if a.properties.File_contexts == nil {
		fileContexts = android.PathForSource(ctx, "system/sepolicy/apex", ctx.ModuleName()+"-file_contexts")
	} else {
		if m, t := android.SrcIsModuleWithTag(*a.properties.File_contexts); m != "" {
			otherModule := android.GetModuleFromPathDep(ctx, m, t)
			fileContextsDir = ctx.OtherModuleDir(otherModule)
		}
		fileContexts = android.PathForModuleSrc(ctx, *a.properties.File_contexts)
	}
	if fileContextsDir == "" {
		fileContextsDir = filepath.Dir(fileContexts.String())
	}
	fileContextsDir += string(filepath.Separator)

	if a.Platform() {
		if !strings.HasPrefix(fileContextsDir, "system/sepolicy/") {
			ctx.PropertyErrorf("file_contexts", "should be under system/sepolicy, but found in  %q", fileContextsDir)
		}
	}
	if !android.ExistentPathForSource(ctx, fileContexts.String()).Valid() {
		ctx.PropertyErrorf("file_contexts", "cannot find file_contexts file: %q", fileContexts.String())
	}

	output := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, "file_contexts")
	rule := android.NewRuleBuilder(pctx, ctx)

	switch a.properties.ApexType {
	case imageApex:
		// remove old file
		rule.Command().Text("rm").FlagWithOutput("-f ", output)
		// copy file_contexts
		rule.Command().Text("cat").Input(fileContexts).Text(">>").Output(output)
		// new line
		rule.Command().Text("echo").Text(">>").Output(output)
		// force-label /apex_manifest.pb and / as system_file so that apexd can read them
		rule.Command().Text("echo").Flag("/apex_manifest\\\\.pb u:object_r:system_file:s0").Text(">>").Output(output)
		rule.Command().Text("echo").Flag("/ u:object_r:system_file:s0").Text(">>").Output(output)
	case flattenedApex:
		// For flattened apexes, install path should be prepended.
		// File_contexts file should be emiited to make via LOCAL_FILE_CONTEXTS
		// so that it can be merged into file_contexts.bin
		apexPath := android.InstallPathToOnDevicePath(ctx, a.installDir.Join(ctx, a.Name()))
		apexPath = strings.ReplaceAll(apexPath, ".", `\\.`)
		// remove old file
		rule.Command().Text("rm").FlagWithOutput("-f ", output)
		// copy file_contexts
		rule.Command().Text("awk").Text(`'/object_r/{printf("` + apexPath + `%s\n", $0)}'`).Input(fileContexts).Text(">").Output(output)
		// new line
		rule.Command().Text("echo").Text(">>").Output(output)
		// force-label /apex_manifest.pb and / as system_file so that apexd can read them
		rule.Command().Text("echo").Flag(apexPath + `/apex_manifest\\.pb u:object_r:system_file:s0`).Text(">>").Output(output)
		rule.Command().Text("echo").Flag(apexPath + "/ u:object_r:system_file:s0").Text(">>").Output(output)
	default:
		panic(fmt.Errorf("unsupported type %v", a.properties.ApexType))
	}

	rule.Build("file_contexts."+a.Name(), "Generate file_contexts")
	return output.OutputPath
}

// buildNoticeFiles creates a buile rule for aggregating notice files from the modules that
// contributes to this APEX. The notice files are merged into a big notice file.
func (a *apexBundle) buildNoticeFiles(ctx android.ModuleContext, apexFileName string) android.NoticeOutputs {
	var noticeFiles android.Paths

	a.WalkPayloadDeps(ctx, func(ctx android.ModuleContext, from blueprint.Module, to android.ApexModule, externalDep bool) bool {
		if externalDep {
			// As soon as the dependency graph crosses the APEX boundary, don't go further.
			return false
		}
		noticeFiles = append(noticeFiles, to.NoticeFiles()...)
		return true
	})

	// TODO(jiyong): why do we need this? WalkPayloadDeps should have already covered this.
	for _, fi := range a.filesInfo {
		noticeFiles = append(noticeFiles, fi.noticeFiles...)
	}

	if len(noticeFiles) == 0 {
		return android.NoticeOutputs{}
	}

	return android.BuildNoticeOutput(ctx, a.installDir, apexFileName, android.SortedUniquePaths(noticeFiles))
}

// buildInstalledFilesFile creates a build rule for the installed-files.txt file where the list of
// files included in this APEX is shown. The text file is dist'ed so that people can see what's
// included in the APEX without actually downloading and extracting it.
func (a *apexBundle) buildInstalledFilesFile(ctx android.ModuleContext, builtApex android.Path, imageDir android.Path) android.OutputPath {
	output := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, "installed-files.txt")
	rule := android.NewRuleBuilder(pctx, ctx)
	rule.Command().
		Implicit(builtApex).
		Text("(cd " + imageDir.String() + " ; ").
		Text("find . \\( -type f -o -type l \\) -printf \"%s %p\\n\") ").
		Text(" | sort -nr > ").
		Output(output)
	rule.Build("installed-files."+a.Name(), "Installed files")
	return output.OutputPath
}

// buildBundleConfig creates a build rule for the bundle config file that will control the bundle
// creation process.
func (a *apexBundle) buildBundleConfig(ctx android.ModuleContext) android.OutputPath {
	output := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, "bundle_config.json")

	type ApkConfig struct {
		Package_name string `json:"package_name"`
		Apk_path     string `json:"path"`
	}
	config := struct {
		Compression struct {
			Uncompressed_glob []string `json:"uncompressed_glob"`
		} `json:"compression"`
		Apex_config struct {
			Apex_embedded_apk_config []ApkConfig `json:"apex_embedded_apk_config,omitempty"`
		} `json:"apex_config,omitempty"`
	}{}

	config.Compression.Uncompressed_glob = []string{
		"apex_payload.img",
		"apex_manifest.*",
	}

	// Collect the manifest names and paths of android apps if their manifest names are
	// overridden.
	for _, fi := range a.filesInfo {
		if fi.class != app && fi.class != appSet {
			continue
		}
		packageName := fi.overriddenPackageName
		if packageName != "" {
			config.Apex_config.Apex_embedded_apk_config = append(
				config.Apex_config.Apex_embedded_apk_config,
				ApkConfig{
					Package_name: packageName,
					Apk_path:     fi.path(),
				})
		}
	}

	j, err := json.Marshal(config)
	if err != nil {
		panic(fmt.Errorf("error while marshalling to %q: %#v", output, err))
	}

	android.WriteFileRule(ctx, output, string(j))

	return output.OutputPath
}

func markManifestTestOnly(ctx android.ModuleContext, androidManifestFile android.Path) android.Path {
	return java.ManifestFixer(java.ManifestFixerParams{
		Ctx:                   ctx,
		Manifest:              androidManifestFile,
		SdkContext:            nil,
		ClassLoaderContexts:   nil,
		IsLibrary:             false,
		UseEmbeddedNativeLibs: false,
		UsesNonSdkApis:        false,
		UseEmbeddedDex:        false,
		HasNoCode:             false,
		TestOnly:              true,
		LoggingParent:         "",
	})
}

// buildUnflattendApex creates build rules to build an APEX using apexer.
func (a *apexBundle) buildUnflattenedApex(ctx android.ModuleContext) {
	apexType := a.properties.ApexType
	suffix := apexType.suffix()
	apexName := proptools.StringDefault(a.properties.Apex_name, a.BaseModuleName())

	////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
	// Step 1: copy built files to appropriate directories under the image directory

	imageDir := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, "image"+suffix)

	installSymbolFiles := !ctx.Config().KatiEnabled() || a.ExportedToMake()

	// b/140136207. When there are overriding APEXes for a VNDK APEX, the symbols file for the overridden
	// APEX and the overriding APEX will have the same installation paths at /apex/com.android.vndk.v<ver>
	// as their apexName will be the same. To avoid the path conflicts, skip installing the symbol files
	// for the overriding VNDK APEXes.
	if a.vndkApex && len(a.overridableProperties.Overrides) > 0 {
		installSymbolFiles = false
	}

	// Avoid creating duplicate build rules for multi-installed APEXes.
	if proptools.BoolDefault(a.properties.Multi_install_skip_symbol_files, false) {
		installSymbolFiles = false

	}
	// set of dependency module:location mappings
	installMapSet := make(map[string]bool)

	// TODO(jiyong): use the RuleBuilder
	var copyCommands []string
	var implicitInputs []android.Path
	pathWhenActivated := android.PathForModuleInPartitionInstall(ctx, "apex", apexName)
	for _, fi := range a.filesInfo {
		destPath := imageDir.Join(ctx, fi.path()).String()
		// Prepare the destination path
		destPathDir := filepath.Dir(destPath)
		if fi.class == appSet {
			copyCommands = append(copyCommands, "rm -rf "+destPathDir)
		}
		copyCommands = append(copyCommands, "mkdir -p "+destPathDir)

		installMapPath := fi.builtFile

		// Copy the built file to the directory. But if the symlink optimization is turned
		// on, place a symlink to the corresponding file in /system partition instead.
		if a.linkToSystemLib && fi.transitiveDep && fi.availableToPlatform() {
			// TODO(jiyong): pathOnDevice should come from fi.module, not being calculated here
			pathOnDevice := filepath.Join("/system", fi.path())
			copyCommands = append(copyCommands, "ln -sfn "+pathOnDevice+" "+destPath)
		} else {
			var installedPath android.InstallPath
			if fi.class == appSet {
				copyCommands = append(copyCommands,
					fmt.Sprintf("unzip -qDD -d %s %s", destPathDir,
						fi.module.(*java.AndroidAppSet).PackedAdditionalOutputs().String()))
				if installSymbolFiles {
					installedPath = ctx.InstallFileWithExtraFilesZip(pathWhenActivated.Join(ctx, fi.installDir),
						fi.stem(), fi.builtFile, fi.module.(*java.AndroidAppSet).PackedAdditionalOutputs())
				}
			} else {
				copyCommands = append(copyCommands, "cp -f "+fi.builtFile.String()+" "+destPath)
				if installSymbolFiles {
					installedPath = ctx.InstallFile(pathWhenActivated.Join(ctx, fi.installDir), fi.stem(), fi.builtFile)
				}
			}
			implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, fi.builtFile)
			if installSymbolFiles {
				implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, installedPath)
			}

			// Create additional symlinks pointing the file inside the APEX (if any). Note that
			// this is independent from the symlink optimization.
			for _, symlinkPath := range fi.symlinkPaths() {
				symlinkDest := imageDir.Join(ctx, symlinkPath).String()
				copyCommands = append(copyCommands, "ln -sfn "+filepath.Base(destPath)+" "+symlinkDest)
				if installSymbolFiles {
					installedSymlink := ctx.InstallSymlink(pathWhenActivated.Join(ctx, filepath.Dir(symlinkPath)), filepath.Base(symlinkPath), installedPath)
					implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, installedSymlink)
				}
			}

			installMapPath = installedPath
		}

		// Copy the test files (if any)
		for _, d := range fi.dataPaths {
			// TODO(eakammer): This is now the third repetition of ~this logic for test paths, refactoring should be possible
			relPath := d.SrcPath.Rel()
			dataPath := d.SrcPath.String()
			if !strings.HasSuffix(dataPath, relPath) {
				panic(fmt.Errorf("path %q does not end with %q", dataPath, relPath))
			}

			dataDest := imageDir.Join(ctx, fi.apexRelativePath(relPath), d.RelativeInstallPath).String()

			copyCommands = append(copyCommands, "cp -f "+d.SrcPath.String()+" "+dataDest)
			implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, d.SrcPath)
		}

		installMapSet[installMapPath.String()+":"+fi.installDir+"/"+fi.builtFile.Base()] = true
	}
	implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, a.manifestPbOut)
	if installSymbolFiles {
		installedManifest := ctx.InstallFile(pathWhenActivated, "apex_manifest.pb", a.manifestPbOut)
		installedKey := ctx.InstallFile(pathWhenActivated, "apex_pubkey", a.publicKeyFile)
		implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, installedManifest, installedKey)
	}

	if len(installMapSet) > 0 {
		var installs []string
		installs = append(installs, android.SortedStringKeys(installMapSet)...)
		a.SetLicenseInstallMap(installs)
	}

	////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
	// Step 1.a: Write the list of files in this APEX to a txt file and compare it against
	// the allowed list given via the allowed_files property. Build fails when the two lists
	// differ.
	//
	// TODO(jiyong): consider removing this. Nobody other than com.android.apex.cts.shim.* seems
	// to be using this at this moment. Furthermore, this looks very similar to what
	// buildInstalledFilesFile does. At least, move this to somewhere else so that this doesn't
	// hurt readability.
	// TODO(jiyong): use RuleBuilder
	if a.overridableProperties.Allowed_files != nil {
		// Build content.txt
		var emitCommands []string
		imageContentFile := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, "content.txt")
		emitCommands = append(emitCommands, "echo ./apex_manifest.pb >> "+imageContentFile.String())
		minSdkVersion := a.minSdkVersion(ctx)
		if minSdkVersion.EqualTo(android.SdkVersion_Android10) {
			emitCommands = append(emitCommands, "echo ./apex_manifest.json >> "+imageContentFile.String())
		}
		for _, fi := range a.filesInfo {
			emitCommands = append(emitCommands, "echo './"+fi.path()+"' >> "+imageContentFile.String())
		}
		emitCommands = append(emitCommands, "sort -o "+imageContentFile.String()+" "+imageContentFile.String())
		ctx.Build(pctx, android.BuildParams{
			Rule:        emitApexContentRule,
			Implicits:   implicitInputs,
			Output:      imageContentFile,
			Description: "emit apex image content",
			Args: map[string]string{
				"emit_commands": strings.Join(emitCommands, " && "),
			},
		})
		implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, imageContentFile)

		// Compare content.txt against allowed_files.
		allowedFilesFile := android.PathForModuleSrc(ctx, proptools.String(a.overridableProperties.Allowed_files))
		phonyOutput := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, a.Name()+"-diff-phony-output")
		ctx.Build(pctx, android.BuildParams{
			Rule:        diffApexContentRule,
			Implicits:   implicitInputs,
			Output:      phonyOutput,
			Description: "diff apex image content",
			Args: map[string]string{
				"allowed_files_file": allowedFilesFile.String(),
				"image_content_file": imageContentFile.String(),
				"apex_module_name":   a.Name(),
			},
		})
		implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, phonyOutput)
	}

	unsignedOutputFile := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, a.Name()+suffix+".unsigned")
	outHostBinDir := ctx.Config().HostToolPath(ctx, "").String()
	prebuiltSdkToolsBinDir := filepath.Join("prebuilts", "sdk", "tools", runtime.GOOS, "bin")

	// Figure out if we need to compress the apex.
	compressionEnabled := ctx.Config().CompressedApex() && proptools.BoolDefault(a.overridableProperties.Compressible, false) && !a.testApex && !ctx.Config().UnbundledBuildApps()
	if apexType == imageApex {

		////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
		// Step 2: create canned_fs_config which encodes filemode,uid,gid of each files
		// in this APEX. The file will be used by apexer in later steps.
		cannedFsConfig := a.buildCannedFsConfig(ctx)
		implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, cannedFsConfig)

		////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
		// Step 3: Prepare option flags for apexer and invoke it to create an unsigned APEX.
		// TODO(jiyong): use the RuleBuilder
		optFlags := []string{}

		fileContexts := a.buildFileContexts(ctx)
		implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, fileContexts)

		implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, a.privateKeyFile, a.publicKeyFile)
		optFlags = append(optFlags, "--pubkey "+a.publicKeyFile.String())

		manifestPackageName := a.getOverrideManifestPackageName(ctx)
		if manifestPackageName != "" {
			optFlags = append(optFlags, "--override_apk_package_name "+manifestPackageName)
		}

		if a.properties.AndroidManifest != nil {
			androidManifestFile := android.PathForModuleSrc(ctx, proptools.String(a.properties.AndroidManifest))

			if a.testApex {
				androidManifestFile = markManifestTestOnly(ctx, androidManifestFile)
			}

			implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, androidManifestFile)
			optFlags = append(optFlags, "--android_manifest "+androidManifestFile.String())
		}

		// Determine target/min sdk version from the context
		// TODO(jiyong): make this as a function
		moduleMinSdkVersion := a.minSdkVersion(ctx)
		minSdkVersion := moduleMinSdkVersion.String()

		// bundletool doesn't understand what "current" is. We need to transform it to
		// codename
		if moduleMinSdkVersion.IsCurrent() || moduleMinSdkVersion.IsNone() {
			minSdkVersion = ctx.Config().DefaultAppTargetSdk(ctx).String()

			if java.UseApiFingerprint(ctx) {
				minSdkVersion = ctx.Config().PlatformSdkCodename() + fmt.Sprintf(".$$(cat %s)", java.ApiFingerprintPath(ctx).String())
				implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, java.ApiFingerprintPath(ctx))
			}
		}
		// apex module doesn't have a concept of target_sdk_version, hence for the time
		// being targetSdkVersion == default targetSdkVersion of the branch.
		targetSdkVersion := strconv.Itoa(ctx.Config().DefaultAppTargetSdk(ctx).FinalOrFutureInt())

		if java.UseApiFingerprint(ctx) {
			targetSdkVersion = ctx.Config().PlatformSdkCodename() + fmt.Sprintf(".$$(cat %s)", java.ApiFingerprintPath(ctx).String())
			implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, java.ApiFingerprintPath(ctx))
		}
		optFlags = append(optFlags, "--target_sdk_version "+targetSdkVersion)
		optFlags = append(optFlags, "--min_sdk_version "+minSdkVersion)

		if a.overridableProperties.Logging_parent != "" {
			optFlags = append(optFlags, "--logging_parent ", a.overridableProperties.Logging_parent)
		}

		a.mergedNotices = a.buildNoticeFiles(ctx, a.Name()+suffix)
		if a.mergedNotices.HtmlGzOutput.Valid() {
			// If there's a NOTICE file, embed it as an asset file in the APEX.
			implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, a.mergedNotices.HtmlGzOutput.Path())
			optFlags = append(optFlags, "--assets_dir "+filepath.Dir(a.mergedNotices.HtmlGzOutput.String()))
		}

		if (moduleMinSdkVersion.GreaterThan(android.SdkVersion_Android10) && !a.shouldGenerateHashtree()) && !compressionEnabled {
			// Apexes which are supposed to be installed in builtin dirs(/system, etc)
			// don't need hashtree for activation. Therefore, by removing hashtree from
			// apex bundle (filesystem image in it, to be specific), we can save storage.
			optFlags = append(optFlags, "--no_hashtree")
		}

		if a.testOnlyShouldSkipPayloadSign() {
			optFlags = append(optFlags, "--unsigned_payload")
		}

		if a.properties.Apex_name != nil {
			// If apex_name is set, apexer can skip checking if key name matches with
			// apex name.  Note that apex_manifest is also mended.
			optFlags = append(optFlags, "--do_not_check_keyname")
		}

		if moduleMinSdkVersion == android.SdkVersion_Android10 {
			implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, a.manifestJsonOut)
			optFlags = append(optFlags, "--manifest_json "+a.manifestJsonOut.String())
		}

		optFlags = append(optFlags, "--payload_fs_type "+a.payloadFsType.string())

		ctx.Build(pctx, android.BuildParams{
			Rule:        apexRule,
			Implicits:   implicitInputs,
			Output:      unsignedOutputFile,
			Description: "apex (" + apexType.name() + ")",
			Args: map[string]string{
				"tool_path":        outHostBinDir + ":" + prebuiltSdkToolsBinDir,
				"image_dir":        imageDir.String(),
				"copy_commands":    strings.Join(copyCommands, " && "),
				"manifest":         a.manifestPbOut.String(),
				"file_contexts":    fileContexts.String(),
				"canned_fs_config": cannedFsConfig.String(),
				"key":              a.privateKeyFile.String(),
				"opt_flags":        strings.Join(optFlags, " "),
			},
		})

		// TODO(jiyong): make the two rules below as separate functions
		apexProtoFile := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, a.Name()+".pb"+suffix)
		bundleModuleFile := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, a.Name()+suffix+"-base.zip")
		a.bundleModuleFile = bundleModuleFile

		ctx.Build(pctx, android.BuildParams{
			Rule:        apexProtoConvertRule,
			Input:       unsignedOutputFile,
			Output:      apexProtoFile,
			Description: "apex proto convert",
		})

		implicitInputs = append(implicitInputs, unsignedOutputFile)

		// Run coverage analysis
		apisUsedbyOutputFile := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, a.Name()+"_using.txt")
		ctx.Build(pctx, android.BuildParams{
			Rule:        generateAPIsUsedbyApexRule,
			Implicits:   implicitInputs,
			Description: "coverage",
			Output:      apisUsedbyOutputFile,
			Args: map[string]string{
				"image_dir": imageDir.String(),
				"readelf":   "${config.ClangBin}/llvm-readelf",
			},
		})
		a.nativeApisUsedByModuleFile = apisUsedbyOutputFile

		var nativeLibNames []string
		for _, f := range a.filesInfo {
			if f.class == nativeSharedLib {
				nativeLibNames = append(nativeLibNames, f.stem())
			}
		}
		apisBackedbyOutputFile := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, a.Name()+"_backing.txt")
		rule := android.NewRuleBuilder(pctx, ctx)
		rule.Command().
			Tool(android.PathForSource(ctx, "build/soong/scripts/gen_ndk_backedby_apex.sh")).
			Output(apisBackedbyOutputFile).
			Flags(nativeLibNames)
		rule.Build("ndk_backedby_list", "Generate API libraries backed by Apex")
		a.nativeApisBackedByModuleFile = apisBackedbyOutputFile

		var javaLibOrApkPath []android.Path
		for _, f := range a.filesInfo {
			if f.class == javaSharedLib || f.class == app {
				javaLibOrApkPath = append(javaLibOrApkPath, f.builtFile)
			}
		}
		javaApiUsedbyOutputFile := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, a.Name()+"_using.xml")
		javaUsedByRule := android.NewRuleBuilder(pctx, ctx)
		javaUsedByRule.Command().
			Tool(android.PathForSource(ctx, "build/soong/scripts/gen_java_usedby_apex.sh")).
			BuiltTool("dexdeps").
			Output(javaApiUsedbyOutputFile).
			Inputs(javaLibOrApkPath)
		javaUsedByRule.Build("java_usedby_list", "Generate Java APIs used by Apex")
		a.javaApisUsedByModuleFile = javaApiUsedbyOutputFile

		bundleConfig := a.buildBundleConfig(ctx)

		var abis []string
		for _, target := range ctx.MultiTargets() {
			if len(target.Arch.Abi) > 0 {
				abis = append(abis, target.Arch.Abi[0])
			}
		}

		abis = android.FirstUniqueStrings(abis)

		ctx.Build(pctx, android.BuildParams{
			Rule:        apexBundleRule,
			Input:       apexProtoFile,
			Implicit:    bundleConfig,
			Output:      a.bundleModuleFile,
			Description: "apex bundle module",
			Args: map[string]string{
				"abi":    strings.Join(abis, "."),
				"config": bundleConfig.String(),
			},
		})
	} else { // zipApex
		ctx.Build(pctx, android.BuildParams{
			Rule:        zipApexRule,
			Implicits:   implicitInputs,
			Output:      unsignedOutputFile,
			Description: "apex (" + apexType.name() + ")",
			Args: map[string]string{
				"tool_path":     outHostBinDir + ":" + prebuiltSdkToolsBinDir,
				"image_dir":     imageDir.String(),
				"copy_commands": strings.Join(copyCommands, " && "),
				"manifest":      a.manifestPbOut.String(),
			},
		})
	}

	////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
	// Step 4: Sign the APEX using signapk
	signedOutputFile := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, a.Name()+suffix)

	pem, key := a.getCertificateAndPrivateKey(ctx)
	rule := java.Signapk
	args := map[string]string{
		"certificates": pem.String() + " " + key.String(),
		"flags":        "-a 4096 --align-file-size", //alignment
	}
	implicits := android.Paths{pem, key}
	if ctx.Config().UseRBE() && ctx.Config().IsEnvTrue("RBE_SIGNAPK") {
		rule = java.SignapkRE
		args["implicits"] = strings.Join(implicits.Strings(), ",")
		args["outCommaList"] = signedOutputFile.String()
	}
	ctx.Build(pctx, android.BuildParams{
		Rule:        rule,
		Description: "signapk",
		Output:      signedOutputFile,
		Input:       unsignedOutputFile,
		Implicits:   implicits,
		Args:        args,
	})
	a.outputFile = signedOutputFile

	if ctx.ModuleDir() != "system/apex/apexd/apexd_testdata" && a.testOnlyShouldForceCompression() {
		ctx.PropertyErrorf("test_only_force_compression", "not available")
		return
	}

	if apexType == imageApex && (compressionEnabled || a.testOnlyShouldForceCompression()) {
		a.isCompressed = true
		unsignedCompressedOutputFile := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, a.Name()+imageCapexSuffix+".unsigned")

		compressRule := android.NewRuleBuilder(pctx, ctx)
		compressRule.Command().
			Text("rm").
			FlagWithOutput("-f ", unsignedCompressedOutputFile)
		compressRule.Command().
			BuiltTool("apex_compression_tool").
			Flag("compress").
			FlagWithArg("--apex_compression_tool ", outHostBinDir+":"+prebuiltSdkToolsBinDir).
			FlagWithInput("--input ", signedOutputFile).
			FlagWithOutput("--output ", unsignedCompressedOutputFile)
		compressRule.Build("compressRule", "Generate unsigned compressed APEX file")

		signedCompressedOutputFile := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, a.Name()+imageCapexSuffix)
		if ctx.Config().UseRBE() && ctx.Config().IsEnvTrue("RBE_SIGNAPK") {
			args["outCommaList"] = signedCompressedOutputFile.String()
		}
		ctx.Build(pctx, android.BuildParams{
			Rule:        rule,
			Description: "sign compressedApex",
			Output:      signedCompressedOutputFile,
			Input:       unsignedCompressedOutputFile,
			Implicits:   implicits,
			Args:        args,
		})
		a.outputFile = signedCompressedOutputFile
	}

	installSuffix := suffix
	if a.isCompressed {
		installSuffix = imageCapexSuffix
	}

	// Install to $OUT/soong/{target,host}/.../apex.
	a.installedFile = ctx.InstallFile(a.installDir, a.Name()+installSuffix, a.outputFile,
		a.compatSymlinks.Paths()...)

	// installed-files.txt is dist'ed
	a.installedFilesFile = a.buildInstalledFilesFile(ctx, a.outputFile, imageDir)
}

// buildFlattenedApex creates rules for a flattened APEX. Flattened APEX actually doesn't have a
// single output file. It is a phony target for all the files under /system/apex/<name> directory.
// This function creates the installation rules for the files.
func (a *apexBundle) buildFlattenedApex(ctx android.ModuleContext) {
	bundleName := a.Name()
	installedSymlinks := append(android.InstallPaths(nil), a.compatSymlinks...)
	if a.installable() {
		for _, fi := range a.filesInfo {
			dir := filepath.Join("apex", bundleName, fi.installDir)
			installDir := android.PathForModuleInstall(ctx, dir)
			if a.linkToSystemLib && fi.transitiveDep && fi.availableToPlatform() {
				// TODO(jiyong): pathOnDevice should come from fi.module, not being calculated here
				pathOnDevice := filepath.Join("/system", fi.path())
				installedSymlinks = append(installedSymlinks,
					ctx.InstallAbsoluteSymlink(installDir, fi.stem(), pathOnDevice))
			} else {
				target := ctx.InstallFile(installDir, fi.stem(), fi.builtFile)
				for _, sym := range fi.symlinks {
					installedSymlinks = append(installedSymlinks,
						ctx.InstallSymlink(installDir, sym, target))
				}
			}
		}

		// Create install rules for the files added in GenerateAndroidBuildActions after
		// buildFlattenedApex is called.  Add the links to system libs (if any) as dependencies
		// of the apex_manifest.pb file since it is always present.
		dir := filepath.Join("apex", bundleName)
		installDir := android.PathForModuleInstall(ctx, dir)
		ctx.InstallFile(installDir, "apex_manifest.pb", a.manifestPbOut, installedSymlinks.Paths()...)
		ctx.InstallFile(installDir, "apex_pubkey", a.publicKeyFile)
	}

	a.fileContexts = a.buildFileContexts(ctx)

	a.outputFile = android.PathForModuleInstall(ctx, "apex", bundleName)
}

// getCertificateAndPrivateKey retrieves the cert and the private key that will be used to sign
// the zip container of this APEX. See the description of the 'certificate' property for how
// the cert and the private key are found.
func (a *apexBundle) getCertificateAndPrivateKey(ctx android.PathContext) (pem, key android.Path) {
	if a.containerCertificateFile != nil {
		return a.containerCertificateFile, a.containerPrivateKeyFile
	}

	cert := String(a.overridableProperties.Certificate)
	if cert == "" {
		return ctx.Config().DefaultAppCertificate(ctx)
	}

	defaultDir := ctx.Config().DefaultAppCertificateDir(ctx)
	pem = defaultDir.Join(ctx, cert+".x509.pem")
	key = defaultDir.Join(ctx, cert+".pk8")
	return pem, key
}

func (a *apexBundle) getOverrideManifestPackageName(ctx android.ModuleContext) string {
	// For VNDK APEXes, check "com.android.vndk" in PRODUCT_MANIFEST_PACKAGE_NAME_OVERRIDES
	// to see if it should be overridden because their <apex name> is dynamically generated
	// according to its VNDK version.
	if a.vndkApex {
		overrideName, overridden := ctx.DeviceConfig().OverrideManifestPackageNameFor(vndkApexName)
		if overridden {
			return strings.Replace(*a.properties.Apex_name, vndkApexName, overrideName, 1)
		}
		return ""
	}
	if a.overridableProperties.Package_name != "" {
		return a.overridableProperties.Package_name
	}
	manifestPackageName, overridden := ctx.DeviceConfig().OverrideManifestPackageNameFor(ctx.ModuleName())
	if overridden {
		return manifestPackageName
	}
	return ""
}

func (a *apexBundle) buildApexDependencyInfo(ctx android.ModuleContext) {
	if !a.primaryApexType {
		return
	}

	if a.properties.IsCoverageVariant {
		// Otherwise, we will have duplicated rules for coverage and
		// non-coverage variants of the same APEX
		return
	}

	if ctx.Host() {
		// No need to generate dependency info for host variant
		return
	}

	depInfos := android.DepNameToDepInfoMap{}
	a.WalkPayloadDeps(ctx, func(ctx android.ModuleContext, from blueprint.Module, to android.ApexModule, externalDep bool) bool {
		if from.Name() == to.Name() {
			// This can happen for cc.reuseObjTag. We are not interested in tracking this.
			// As soon as the dependency graph crosses the APEX boundary, don't go further.
			return !externalDep
		}

		// Skip dependencies that are only available to APEXes; they are developed with updatability
		// in mind and don't need manual approval.
		if to.(android.ApexModule).NotAvailableForPlatform() {
			return !externalDep
		}

		depTag := ctx.OtherModuleDependencyTag(to)
		// Check to see if dependency been marked to skip the dependency check
		if skipDepCheck, ok := depTag.(android.SkipApexAllowedDependenciesCheck); ok && skipDepCheck.SkipApexAllowedDependenciesCheck() {
			return !externalDep
		}

		if info, exists := depInfos[to.Name()]; exists {
			if !android.InList(from.Name(), info.From) {
				info.From = append(info.From, from.Name())
			}
			info.IsExternal = info.IsExternal && externalDep
			depInfos[to.Name()] = info
		} else {
			toMinSdkVersion := "(no version)"
			if m, ok := to.(interface {
				MinSdkVersion(ctx android.EarlyModuleContext) android.SdkSpec
			}); ok {
				if v := m.MinSdkVersion(ctx); !v.ApiLevel.IsNone() {
					toMinSdkVersion = v.ApiLevel.String()
				}
			} else if m, ok := to.(interface{ MinSdkVersion() string }); ok {
				// TODO(b/175678607) eliminate the use of MinSdkVersion returning
				// string
				if v := m.MinSdkVersion(); v != "" {
					toMinSdkVersion = v
				}
			}
			depInfos[to.Name()] = android.ApexModuleDepInfo{
				To:            to.Name(),
				From:          []string{from.Name()},
				IsExternal:    externalDep,
				MinSdkVersion: toMinSdkVersion,
			}
		}

		// As soon as the dependency graph crosses the APEX boundary, don't go further.
		return !externalDep
	})

	a.ApexBundleDepsInfo.BuildDepsInfoLists(ctx, proptools.String(a.properties.Min_sdk_version), depInfos)

	ctx.Build(pctx, android.BuildParams{
		Rule:   android.Phony,
		Output: android.PathForPhony(ctx, a.Name()+"-deps-info"),
		Inputs: []android.Path{
			a.ApexBundleDepsInfo.FullListPath(),
			a.ApexBundleDepsInfo.FlatListPath(),
		},
	})
}

func (a *apexBundle) buildLintReports(ctx android.ModuleContext) {
	depSetsBuilder := java.NewLintDepSetBuilder()
	for _, fi := range a.filesInfo {
		depSetsBuilder.Transitive(fi.lintDepSets)
	}

	a.lintReports = java.BuildModuleLintReportZips(ctx, depSetsBuilder.Build())
}

func (a *apexBundle) buildCannedFsConfig(ctx android.ModuleContext) android.OutputPath {
	var readOnlyPaths = []string{"apex_manifest.json", "apex_manifest.pb"}
	var executablePaths []string // this also includes dirs
	var appSetDirs []string
	appSetFiles := make(map[string]android.Path)
	for _, f := range a.filesInfo {
		pathInApex := f.path()
		if f.installDir == "bin" || strings.HasPrefix(f.installDir, "bin/") {
			executablePaths = append(executablePaths, pathInApex)
			for _, d := range f.dataPaths {
				readOnlyPaths = append(readOnlyPaths, filepath.Join(f.installDir, d.RelativeInstallPath, d.SrcPath.Rel()))
			}
			for _, s := range f.symlinks {
				executablePaths = append(executablePaths, filepath.Join(f.installDir, s))
			}
		} else if f.class == appSet {
			appSetDirs = append(appSetDirs, f.installDir)
			appSetFiles[f.installDir] = f.builtFile
		} else {
			readOnlyPaths = append(readOnlyPaths, pathInApex)
		}
		dir := f.installDir
		for !android.InList(dir, executablePaths) && dir != "" {
			executablePaths = append(executablePaths, dir)
			dir, _ = filepath.Split(dir) // move up to the parent
			if len(dir) > 0 {
				// remove trailing slash
				dir = dir[:len(dir)-1]
			}
		}
	}
	sort.Strings(readOnlyPaths)
	sort.Strings(executablePaths)
	sort.Strings(appSetDirs)

	cannedFsConfig := android.PathForModuleOut(ctx, "canned_fs_config")
	builder := android.NewRuleBuilder(pctx, ctx)
	cmd := builder.Command()
	cmd.Text("(")
	cmd.Text("echo '/ 1000 1000 0755';")
	for _, p := range readOnlyPaths {
		cmd.Textf("echo '/%s 1000 1000 0644';", p)
	}
	for _, p := range executablePaths {
		cmd.Textf("echo '/%s 0 2000 0755';", p)
	}
	for _, dir := range appSetDirs {
		cmd.Textf("echo '/%s 0 2000 0755';", dir)
		file := appSetFiles[dir]
		cmd.Text("zipinfo -1").Input(file).Textf(`| sed "s:\(.*\):/%s/\1 1000 1000 0644:";`, dir)
	}
	// Custom fs_config is "appended" to the last so that entries from the file are preferred
	// over default ones set above.
	if a.properties.Canned_fs_config != nil {
		cmd.Text("cat").Input(android.PathForModuleSrc(ctx, *a.properties.Canned_fs_config))
	}
	cmd.Text(")").FlagWithOutput("> ", cannedFsConfig)
	builder.Build("generateFsConfig", fmt.Sprintf("Generating canned fs config for %s", a.BaseModuleName()))

	return cannedFsConfig.OutputPath
}