Current behavior:
Assume not checkpointing
cp_startCheckpoint creates the file in metadata
cp_needsCheckpoint will now set isCheckpointing to true
cp_commitCheckpoint will now think there is a checkpoint, and try to
commit it. This will fail on ext4 and it will return false, leading to
bad things.
cp_startCheckpoint is called when staging an apex module for update.
After this point, several things could go wrong:
If a keystore key is deleted, it calls cp_needsCheckpoint to see if the
delete should be deferred until cp_commitCheckpoint. The delete will now
be deferred, meaning that this key will never be deleted, using up the
key sots in trustzone
If a trim is scheduled through idle maintenance, this also calls
cp_needsCheckpoint, so the trims will not occur.
If either of these happens before a system crash, the device will not
recover since the system calls commitCheckpoint which will now crash.
When the system then goes on to reboot, the checkpoint will not be
triggered, since the commitCheckpoint call will have deleted the
checkpoint flag file before crashing.
Bug: 138952436
Test: vdc checkpoint startCheckpoint 5
vdc checkpoint needsCheckpoint
vdc checkpoint commitChanges
stop;start
commitChanges fails, then device loops
After applying this test, commitChanges succeeds and device does
not loop
Change-Id: I135099625f77344d1f8d2e8688735871c44ef2f5
If cp_commitCheckpoint is called twice at the same time, the second call
to setBowState will fail.
Add lock to remove possibility, and protect all uses of isCheckpointing
Bug: 138952436
Test: Boots after flashing in checkpoint mode
Change-Id: I131298adc506c3c176774d15e642b13d5f991087
am: 3507d68556 -s ours
am skip reason: change_id I20441964dbc7b6ad5b445fa17a1374c1282bbbd8 with SHA1 3f1ce062d5 is in history
Change-Id: I2a5fe3fc7bbf3af55facde1ab07bd0559d8e7d87
am: dde9704664 -s ours
am skip reason: change_id I8365a40298b752af4bb10d00d9ff58ce04beab1f with SHA1 236e5e800e is in history
Change-Id: I11c77206000895c27aee9ad8326778ec95e233df
When both ext4 user data checkpoints and metadata encryption are
enabled, we are creating two stacked dm devices. This had not been
properly thought through or debugged.
Test: Enable metadata encryption on taimen (add
keydirectory=/metadata/vold/metadata_encryption to flags for userdata in
fstab.hardware)
Unfortunately metadata is not wiped by fastboot -w, so it is
necessary to rm metadata/vold -rf whenever you wipe data.
fastboot flashall -w works
fastboot reboot -w works
A normal boot works
Disable checkpoint commits with
setprop persist.vold.dont_commit_checkpoint 1
vdc checkpoint startCheckpoint 10
adb reboot
wait for device to fully boot then
adb reboot
Wait for device to fully boot then
adb logcat -d | grep Checkpoint shows the rollback in the logs
This tests encryption on top of checkpoints with commit, encryption
without checkpoints, and rollback, which seems to be the key cases.
Also ran same tests on unmodified Taimen and Blueline
Bug: 135905679
Merged-In: I8365a40298b752af4bb10d00d9ff58ce04beab1f
Change-Id: I8365a40298b752af4bb10d00d9ff58ce04beab1f
When both ext4 user data checkpoints and metadata encryption are
enabled, we are creating two stacked dm devices. This had not been
properly thought through or debugged.
Test: Enable metadata encryption on taimen (add
keydirectory=/metadata/vold/metadata_encryption to flags for userdata in
fstab.hardware)
Unfortunately metadata is not wiped by fastboot -w, so it is
necessary to rm metadata/vold -rf whenever you wipe data.
fastboot flashall -w works
fastboot reboot -w works
A normal boot works
Disable checkpoint commits with
setprop persist.vold.dont_commit_checkpoint 1
vdc checkpoint startCheckpoint 10
adb reboot
wait for device to fully boot then
adb reboot
Wait for device to fully boot then
adb logcat -d | grep Checkpoint shows the rollback in the logs
This tests encryption on top of checkpoints with commit, encryption
without checkpoints, and rollback, which seems to be the key cases.
Bug: 135905679
Change-Id: I8365a40298b752af4bb10d00d9ff58ce04beab1f
am: 3601f4790b -s ours
am skip reason: change_id I1d50a7e52fda34e59eb6f051c7fde115a6cd5255 with SHA1 3d3a9a7f1c is in history
Change-Id: Ib97568c9eaecb3c52e4703f7d14a8235b9cc0cc4
